Epidemiology
: in 1958, Dennis Burkitt first described a disorder associated with jaw
tumours in African childrenref.
In 1961, the neoplasm was identified as a form of malignant lymphoma, and
what had initially emerged as a clinical syndrome became a pathological
entity called Burkitt’s lymphoma (BL)ref.
It is the most frequent tumor in children aged 5 to 9 years in equatorial
Sub-Saharan Africa, South America, and Papua New Guinea. The overall incidence
of BL in the USA was 1.4 per million for white males and 0.4 per million
for white females during 1973-1981ref.
BL accounts for 30 to 50% of lymphomas in children but only 1 to 2% of
lymphomas in adultsref Aetiology :
endemic Burkitt's lymphoma
(eBL)ref
affects mostly children. The most common site of involvement of endemic
BL is the kidneys. Jaw tumours are age related with an overall incidence
in Uganda of 50%ref.
HHV-4 / EBV
is contained in all eBL cells, thus implicating it as a likely etiologic
factor. Viral expression is reduced essentially to small non-coding RNA,
non-polyadenilates, and EBERs (106 copies per cell) and EBNA1
: expression of EBNA in transgenes leads to lymphoma in mice and could
play a role in the expression of the c-myc gene involved in translocations.
Very early (during the first months of life) EBV infection observed in
North or equatorial Africa increases the risk of BL by 20-times that in
Europe. EBV is considered by some an advantage for selectionref
impairment of EBV-specific CTL immune responses by :
malaria
: geographic distribution of eBL appears to be related to climatic conditions
and coincides with areas of holoendemic malarial infection, which is thought
to facilitate this oncogenic process. Acute Plasmodium falciparum
malaria infection in African children allows expansion of latent EBV infection
=> increase in the number of EBV-containing B-cells in the circulation,
lymph nodes (in 60% of cases)ref
and cell-free EBV DNA in plasmaref.
In healthy seropositive adults, the EBV-carrying B cell is predominantly
within the IgM+IgD+ circulating virgin B cells recently
released from the bone marrow but not the IgG+ subpopulations.
These B cells have an estimated life span of only 6-8 weeks suggesting
that long-term EBV persistence in the body may be the result of infection
of a more primitive B-cell type. In children with acute malaria EBV-carrying
B cells are also found in the IgM+, IgG- B-cell subpopulation.
The majority of these cells are found in the low-density (large cell) Percoll
fraction although in some patients a proportion was derived from the high-density
(small cell) fraction. This cellular phenotype is not representative of
a BL cell. Control of malaria endemicity has been associated with reduced
incidence of eBLref
chronic schistosomiasis
is associated with elevated Th2
cytokine expression resulting in reduced cell-mediated cytotoxicityref
Models :
Klein’s model : EBV infection => malaria
infection =>
Bornkamm’s model : germinal center
B-cell => malaria infection => increased c-MYC => EBV infection
Niller-Minarovits model :
binding of transcription factor and oncoprotein c-Myc to the major locus
control region (LCR) of the viral genome directs us to an alternative model
for the origin of Burkitt's lymphoma (BL). In this model, improved nuclear
maintenance of the viral genome and the continuous expression of anti-apoptotic
functions in B cells exhibiting class I EBV latency contribute to the generation
of BL, without any detour through EBV nuclear antigen (EBNA) 2-driven B-cell
immortalization (also called class III latency)ref1,
ref2.
Niller-Minarovits ping-pong evolution hypothesis : persisting viruses
served as a complement for the organismal germline like in a ping-pong
game The left part of the EBV genome exhibits a strong colinearity of structural
and functional elements with the Ig gene loci which is only partially reflected
in nucleotide sequence homologies. This colinearity may be the result of
an inter-dependent co-evolution of the immunoglobulin loci together with
EBV. Our observation could help elucidating the mechanisms of somatic hypermutation,
explaining the ability of EBV to accidentally cause tumors, and shedding
more light on the general mechanisms of viral and organismal evolutionref.
There are 2 main classes of Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) associated lymphomas:
primarily malignant Burkitt's Lymphoma (BL) and Hodgkin's Disease (HD),
on one hand, and primarily benign lymphoproliferations, e.g., post-transplant
lymphoproliferative disease (PTLD) on the other hand. PTLD may start as
a benign lymphoproliferation which becomes malignant if out of T cell control
for too long. Our discovery of a binding site for the oncoprotein c-Myc
at a central position of the EBV genome favours a distinction of pathogenetic
pathways or scenarios for the proposed lymphoma classes. In the first scenario
nuclear maintenance of the EBV genome and activation of viral anti-apoptotic
functions with the help of c-Myc are indispensable for the origin of malignant
tumours (BL, HD) from the germinal centre B-cell. In the second scenario
expression of the main viral transforming protein EBNA2 is essential for
immortalisation and non-malignant morphological transformation of any (germinal
centre derived or non-germinal centre) B-cell in the absence of T cell
control. Although EBNA2 expression is permissible, under specific circumstances,
in malignant B-cells, it is not required for oncogenesisref.
LMP2A has been implicated in EBV related tumorigenesis. To understand
the host cell dependent expression of the LMP2A gene, it is necessary to
analyse the regulatory mechanisms of the LMP2A promoter (LMP2Ap). By transient
transfection and in vitro binding analyses two CBF1 sites have previously
been shown to be involved in the regulation of LMP2Ap. However, the promoter
structure has not been examined at the nucleotide level in vivo. Therefore
we undertook a comprehensive analysis of in vivo protein binding
and of CpG-methylation patterns at LMP2Ap in a panel of B cell lines carrying
latent EBV genomes. The presence of characteristic footprints on two CBF1
and further binding-sites, together with overall hypomethylation of CpG
dinucleotides correlated well with promoter activity. In contrast, the
absence of several genomic footprints, as well as the presence of patches
of highly methylated CpG dinucleotides were characteristic of silent LMP2Apsref.
The viral interleukin-10 promoter (vIL-10p), overlapping the rep* element
in the EBV genome, is a promoter element active mostly in the late phase
of the lytic cycle and immediately upon infection of B cells. rep* was,
through transfection experiments with small plasmids, characterised as
a cis element supporting oriP replicative function. In this study, in
vivo protein binding and CpG methylation at rep*/vIL-10p were analysed
in five cell lines that harbour strictly latent EBV genomes. Contrary to
the invariably unmethylated dyad symmetry element (DS) of oriP, rep*/vIL-10p
was highly methylated and showed only traces of protein binding in all
examined cell lines. This result is in agreement with vIL-10p being an
inactive promoter of EBV genomes, and makes it less likely that rep* functions
as a replicative element of latent EBV genomesref.
We analysed the methylation patterns of CpG dinucleotides in a bidirectional
promoter region (LRS, LMP 1 regulatory sequences) of latent EBV genomes
using automated fluorescent genomic sequencing after bisulfite-induced
modification of DNA. Transcripts for 2 latent membrane proteins, LMP1 (a
transforming protein) and LMP2B, are initiated in this region in opposite
directions. B cell lines and a clone expressing LMP 1 carried EBV genomes
with unmethylated or hypomethylated LRS, while highly methylated CpG dinucleotides
were present at each position or at discrete sites and within hypermethylated
regions in LMP 1 negative cells. Comparison of high resolution methylation
maps suggests that CpG methylation-mediated direct interference with binding
of nuclear factors LBF 2, 3, 7, AML1/LBF1, LBF5 and LBF6 or methylation
of CpGs within an E-box sequence (where activators as well as repressors
can bind) is not the major mechanism in silencing of the LMP 1 promoter.
Although a role for CpG methylation within binding sites of Sp1 and 3,
ATF/CRE and a sis-inducible factor (SIF) cannot be excluded, hypermethylation
of LRS or regions within LRS in LMP 1 negative cells suggests a role for
an indirect mechanism, via methylcytosine binding proteins, in silencing
of the LMP 1 promoterref.
EBV latency-associated promoters Qp, Cp, and LMP1p are crucial for
the regulated expression of the EBNA and LMP transcripts in dependence
of the latency type. By transient transfection and in vitro binding
analyses, many promoter elements and transcription factors have previously
been shown to be involved in the activities of these promoters. However,
the latency promoters have only partially been examined at the nucleotide
level in vivo. Therefore, we undertook a comprehensive analysis
of in vivo protein binding and CpG methylation patterns at these promoters
in five representative cell lines and correlated the results with the known
in
vitro binding data and activities of these promoters from previous
transfection experiments. Promoter activity inversely correlated with the
methylation state of promoters, although Qp was a remarkable exception.
Novel protein binding data were obtained for all promoters. For Cp, binding
correlated well with promoter activity; for LMP1p and Qp, binding patterns
looked similar regardless of promoter activityref.
van den Bosch model : EBV => arbovirus
(> malaria. Geographical and age distributions of eBL in Africa parallel
those of certain potentially oncogenic, mosquito-borne arboviruses. Arboviruses
seem to be associated with case clusters of endemic Burkitt's lymphoma,
and symptoms compatible with arbovirus infection have been seen immediately
before the onset of the tumour. Chikungunya
virusref)
=> plant promoters (Euphorbia
tirucalli,
the distribution of which coincides with the boundaries of the lymphoma
belt : RNA and DNA viruses, including EBV, are promoted by extracts of
this commonly used plant. Extracts of E. tirucalli are tumour promoters
and can induce the characteristic 8;14 translocation of endemic Burkitt's
lymphoma in EBV-infected cell-lines. They also activate latent EBV in infected
cells, enhance EBV-mediated cell transformation, and modulate EBV-specific
immunityref)
microarray models : gene signatures analyzed by cDNA microarray,
and they were validated by immunohistochemistry, flow cytometry, and Western
blotting
TIMP-1 repressed expression of germinal center (GC) markers CD10, Bcl-6,
PAX-5 and up-regulated plasma cell-associated antigens CD138, MUM-1/IRF-4,
XBP-1, and CD44, suggesting a plasma cell differentiation. This is accompanied
by activation of STAT-3 and switch to cyclin D2 expression. However, TIMP-1JD38
cells expressed an inactive form of XBP-1, lacking antibody production/secretion.
This incomplete plasmacytic differentiation occurs without altering cell
proliferation, and despite c-Myc deregulation, indicating an arrested plasmacytic/plasmablastic
stage of differentiation. Further validation in human lymphoma cell lines
and in primary B-cell tumors demonstrated a predominant TIMP-1 expression
in tumors with plasmacytic/plasmablastic phenotypes, including multiple
myelomasref
EBNA-2 upregulates IL-16, an immunomodulatory cytokine involved in the
regulation of CD4 T cells, and AML-2, a member of the Runt domain family
of transcription factors. AML-2 expression is normally predominant in EBV
latency III, whereas AML-1 is associated with EBV latency I or EBV-
cellsref.
EBNA2 induces expression of the 2 chains of the IL-18R in Burkitt lymphoma
(BL) cell lines and in nontransformed B cells. Activation of IL-18R expression
by EBNA2 is independent of its interaction with the transcriptional repressor
RBPJ kappa. It occurs in the absence of any other viral protein but requires
de
novo synthesis of cellular proteins. IL-18R induction is a highly specific
function of EBNA2, because neither other EBV latent proteins nor the cellular
proteins c-myc or Notch can exert this effect. Using cDNA microarray expression
profiling, we find that the IL-18 receptor expressed in EBV-infected BL
cells has signaling capacity, because IL-18 significantly modified gene
expression. EBNA2 expression is associated with IL-18R expression in
vivo in EBV+ B-lymphomas from AIDS patientsref.
Kuppers-Dalla-Favera :
Hodgkin and Reed-Sternberg (HRS) cells represent the malignant cells in
classical Hodgkin lymphoma (HL). Because their immunophenotype cannot be
attributed to any normal cell of the hematopoietic lineage, the origin
of HRS cells has been controversially discussed, but molecular studies
established their derivation from germinal center B cells. In this study,
gene expression profiles generated by serial analysis of gene expression
(SAGE) and DNA chip microarrays from HL cell lines were compared with those
of normal B-cell subsets, focusing here on the expression of B-lineage
markers. This analysis revealed decreased mRNA levels for nearly all established
B-lineage-specific genes. For 9 of these genes, lack of protein expression
was histochemically confirmed. Down-regulation of genes affected multiple
components of signaling pathways active in B cells, including B-cell receptor
(BCR) signaling. Because several genes down-regulated in HRS cells are
positively regulated by the transcriptional activator Pax-5, which is expressed
in most HRS cells, we studied HL cell lines for mutations in the Pax-5
gene. However, no mutations were found. We propose that the lost B-lineage
identity in HRS cells may explain their survival without BCR expression
and reflect a fundamental defect in maintaining the B-cell differentiation
state in HRS cells, which is likely caused by a novel, yet unknown, pathogenic
mechanismref.
Hodgkin lymphoma (HL) is a malignancy of unknown pathogenesis. The malignant
Hodgkin and Reed/Sternberg (HRS) cells derive from germinal center B cells
(or rarely, T cells) but have a heterogeneous and largely uncharacterized
phenotype. Using microarrays, we compared the gene expression profile of
four HL cell lines with profiles of the main B cell subsets and B cell
non-HLs to find out whether HRS cells, despite their described heterogeneity,
show a distinct gene expression, to study their relationship to other normal
and malignant B cells, and to identify genes aberrantly or overexpressed
by HRS cells. The HL lines indeed clustered as a distinct entity, irrespective
of their B or T cell derivation, and their gene expression was most similar
to that of EBV-transformed B cells and cell lines derived from diffuse
large cell lymphomas showing features of in vitro-activated B cells.
27 genes, most of which were previously unknown to be expressed by HRS
cells, showed aberrant expression specifically in these cells, e.g., the
transcription factors GATA-3, ABF1, EAR3, and Nrf3. For five genes, expression
in primary HRS cells was confirmed. The newly identified HL-specific genes
may play important roles in the pathogenesis of HL, potentially represent
novel diagnostic markers, and can be considered for therapeutic targetingref.
reciprocal chromosomal translocations involving the Ig loci are a hallmark
of most mature B cell lymphomas and usually result in dysregulated expression
of oncogenes brought under the control of the Ig enhancers. Although the
precise mechanisms involved in the development of these translocations
remains essentially unknown, a clear relationship has been established
with the mechanisms that lead to Ig gene remodeling, including V(D)J recombination,
isotype switching and somatic hypermutation. The common denominator of
these three processes in the formation of Ig-associated translocations
is probably represented by the fact that each of these processes intrinsically
generates double-strand DNA breaks. Since isotype switching and somatic
hypermutation occur in GC B cells, the origin of a large number of B cell
lymphomas from GC B cells is likely closely related to aberrant hypermutation
and isotype switching activity in these B cellsref.
genomic instability promotes tumorigenesis and can occur through various
mechanisms, including defective segregation of chromosomes or inactivation
of DNA mismatch repair. Although B-cell lymphomas are associated with chromosomal
translocations that deregulate oncogene expression, a mechanism for genome-wide
instability during lymphomagenesis has not been described. During B-cell
development, the immunoglobulin variable (V) region genes are subject to
somatic hypermutation in germinal-centre B cells. Here we report that an
aberrant hypermutation activity targets multiple loci, including the proto-oncogenes
PIM1, MYC, RhoH/TTF (ARHH) and PAX5, in more than 50% of diffuse large-cell
lymphomas (DLCLs), which are tumours derived from germinal centres. Mutations
are distributed in the 5' untranslated or coding sequences, are independent
of chromosomal translocations, and share features typical of V-region-associated
somatic hypermutation. In contrast to mutations in V regions, however,
these mutations are not detectable in normal germinal-centre B cells or
in other germinal-centre-derived lymphomas, suggesting a DLCL-associated
malfunction of somatic hypermutation. Intriguingly, the four hypermutable
genes are susceptible to chromosomal translocations in the same region,
consistent with a role for hypermutation in generating translocations by
DNA double-strand breaks. By mutating multiple genes, and possibly by favouring
chromosomal translocations, aberrant hypermutation may represent the major
contributor to lymphomagenesisref.
Thorley-Lawson modelref
: LMP1 and LMP2A--allow EBV to exploit the normal pathways of B-cell differentiation
so that the EBV-infected B blast can become a resting memory cellref.
EBV is a human herpesvirus that infects over 90% of the world's adult population.
Although EBV infection is usually benign, it is associated with several
neoplasias and is the causative agent of acute infectious mononucleosis
(AIM)ref.
As with other herpesviruses, primary infection by EBV is followed by lifelong
persistence. EBV persists in resting, recirculating memory B lymphocytesref1,
ref2,
ref3.
We have previously presented evidenceref
in support of a modelref1,
ref2,
ref3
whereby EBV gains access to memory B cells by using different transcription
programs to first activate latently infected cells and then allow them
to differentiate into resting memory B cells. One major unresolved issue
with EBV in vivo is the nature of the cells responsible for replicating
the virus and the signals necessary to drive a latently infected cell into
viral replication. Lytic replication of EBV occurs regularly in healthy
carriers, since virus particles are found in their salivaref.
It is assumed that the latently infected memory B cells circulating in
the body return periodically to Waldeyer's ring (tonsils and adenoids)ref,
where they undergo periodic reactivation to produce infectious virus to
be shed into saliva. The signal that initiates viral replication in
vivo is unknown; however, we assume that it is not provided by the
virus, since viral proteins are not expressed in the latently infected
memory cellsref.
The process of activating normal memory cells in lymph nodes usually causes
them to differentiate into antibody-producing plasma cellsref.
These cells are essentially biochemical factories, so they would be ideal
for the efficient production of virions. Also, they are located in the
tonsil epitheliumref1,
ref2,
which would allow them to shed virus into the saliva. The first suggestion
that EBV replication may be associated with terminal differentiation came
from an early study that detected expression of a poorly characterized,
plasma cell-associated surface marker (PC1) on cells replicating the virus
in tissue culture cell linesref.
It has also been reportedref1,
ref2
that very rare cells, in tonsils from AIM patients, express proteins from
the viral lytic cycle. The cells were detected by immunohistochemistry
and resembled plasma cells morphologically. These results need to be interpreted
with care, however, since immunohistochemical studies are prone to artifacts,
especially when detecting rare positive cells for which no independent
verification of infection status or cell phenotype is established. These
concerns are highlighted because those authors also observed rare infected
cells bearing T-cell markers. Since infection of T cells is not normally
associated with EBV, this raises concerns that the rare cells replicating
EBV in AIM tonsils are artifacts or aberrations of the very high levels
of infection found in AIM. It was also unresolved whether plasma cell differentiation
is the signal for reactivation or whether reactivation results in plasma
cell differentiation. EBV reactivation has been extensively studied in
vitro with latently infected cell lines. Lytic replication begins through
expression of the immediate-early transcription factor BZLF1ref.
BZLF1 then initiates a cascade of gene expression beginning with the early
genes, some of which are involved in viral DNA replication, and late genes,
which are expressed after viral DNA synthesis and include components of
the virion. Various signals have been shown to trigger rapid induction
of the promoter for BZLF1ref
and to induce viral replication in cultureref1,
ref2.
Although these in vitro systems employ potential differentiation
signalsref1,
ref2
to initiate viral replication, terminal differentiation of cells replicating
the virus into plasma cells is not observed. Thus, the in vitro
studies stand in contrast to the histochemical studies, and it is unclear
what, if any, relationship exists between plasma cell differentiation and
induction of viral replication. In this paper we address the question of
which cell type initiates viral replication in the tonsils of healthy carriers
by separating subsets of tonsil cells and identifying which ones express
the BZLF1 gene. We identify the plasma cell as the cell type in which EBV
undergoes reactivation in vivo in human tonsils and provide evidence
that the terminal differentiation of B cells into plasma cells may provide
the signal that triggers the switch from latency into the lytic cycle.
The cells that initiate EBV replication, i.e., express the immediate-early
gene BZLF1, in the tonsils have the phenotype of plasma cells (CD38hi,
CD10–, CD19+, CD20lo, IgD–,
surface Ig–, and cytoplasmic Ig+). Unfortunately,
cells expressing viral late proteins were extremely rare, and we have no
way to test whether infectious virus is actually produced by this population.
These technical difficulties make it difficult to conclude with certainty
that plasma cells actually produce infectious virus, although they clearly
initiate replication. The possibility that the replication is abortive
cannot be excluded at this time. The main arguments against this conclusion
are that we did detect single BcLF1+ cells in some experiments,
we showed that memory cells have to differentiate into plasma cells before
the BZLF1 promoter is activated, and plasma cells were the only population
where a significant fraction of the infected cells initiate replication
based on BZLF1 expression. Therefore, if virus is being produced by any
B-cell subset, it must be in the plasma cells. Viral replication was not
detected in naive (IgD+ CD38– CD20+) or
germinal center (CD10+ CD38+ CD20+) cells.
Rare cells expressing BZLF1 or early or late antigens were found in the
CD38+ fraction, but these probably represent contamination by
a small number of CD38hi cells. For example, 25% of the infected
CD38hi cells were BZLF1 positive for tonsil 1, whereas only 0.1% of the
infected CD38+ cells were BZLF1 positive. Since there are similar frequencies
of virus-infected cells in both populations, it would take only a 0.5%
contamination of CD38hi cells in the CD38+ population to account for this
result. Most likely, therefore, the BZLF1 signals in the CD38+
population are caused by small numbers of contaminating CD38hi cells. Even
if there was no contamination and the CD38+ signals were real,
the ratio of CD38hi to CD38+ to CD38– B cells in the tonsil
is 1:10:30ref.
Therefore, in absolute terms, 25 out of every 26 (95%) BZLF1-expressing
cells reside in the CD38hi population for tonsil 1. Similarly,
85% can be estimated to reside in the CD38hi population for
tonsil 2. Plasma cells are not thought to be self-renewing, and therefore
it is unlikely that they are in themselves a site of persistent infection.
This is because the infected cells would be rapidly depleted when they
die producing infectious virus. EBV could persist through chronic reinfection
and replication in plasma cells; however, this is unlikely because they
do not express a known viral receptor and there is no evidence that plasma
cells can be directly infected. It is most likely that plasma cells replicating
the virus are produced through terminal differentiation of a small number
of cells from the pool of latently infected circulating resting memory
cells that are generally believed to be the site of long-term persistent
infection for EBVref1,
ref2.
It follows that these cells must circulate back to Waldeyer's ringref,
where they occasionally undergo viral replication to release infectious
virus into the salivaref.
There are 2 possible mechanisms by which EBV in a tonsil memory cell could
be induced to replicate:
viral replication is initiated in memory cells that subsequently differentiate
into plasma cells
latently infected memory cells differentiate into plasma cells and then
initiate viral replication.
We favor the second mechanism. The observation that BZLF1 is predominantly
expressed in the plasma cell fraction together with our quantitation showing
that only about a quarter of the infected plasma cells express BZLF1 implies
that infected memory cells differentiate into plasma cells while remaining
latently infected and then initiate viral replication. This conclusion
is supported by our in vitro studies demonstrating that the BZLF1
promoter functions in memory cells only after they have been driven in
culture to become plasma cells. Since this process takes 7 days, it is
apparent that lytic replication is induced by plasma cell differentiation
and not by the acute signals that drive the differentiation. Plasma cell
differentiation is the signal for initiating viral replication rather than
that viral replication allows or drives cellular differentiation. Since
the circulating, latently infected memory cells express no viral proteinsref,
the signal that causes them to undergo terminal differentiation in vivo
is probably host derived. An explanation for how this could work is offered
by elegant studies demonstrating that immunological B-cell memory does
not require antigen but may be sustained by polyclonal stimuli provided
by bystander T-cell helpref.
This mechanism provides for continuous renewal of memory cells through
sporadic division, which also produces plasma cells and antibody. The result
is maintenance of the memory population while stable levels of antibody
are produced over time in the absence of antigen. Applied to EBV, this
would explain how the population of latently infected memory cells can
be maintained at stable levels for yearsref
while, through the continuous generation of plasma cells, virus can also
be continuously producedref.
A model of how EBV may persist in the circulating memory B-cell compartment
while being continuously shed into saliva, based on the work of Bernasconi
et alref.
They have suggested that memory B cells exposed to bystander T-cell help
become activated and divide, generating new memory cells and plasma cells.
This process maintains the level of memory cells and antibody-secreting
plasma cells in an antigen-independent way. If the memory B cell contained
latent EBV, the process would produce another latently infected memory
cell, maintaining the levels of latently infected cells in the peripheral
circulation, while also producing a plasma cell, thus also ensuring the
continuous release of infectious virus. Since this process occurs in the
tonsils, the plasma cell would migrate into the lymphoepithelium and produce
the virus. Whether this virus is released directly into saliva or is first
amplified through lytic infection of epithelial cells is a controversial
and, as yet, unresolved issue.
An alternate hypothesis is that plasma cell generation is stimulated
by cognate antigen and T-cell help. This would mean that EBV becomes reactivated
when the latently infected memory cell undergoes an antigen-specific secondary
response. This hypothesis has the attractive feature that latency is established
in antigen-specific memory cells in the tonsil. These cells would then
enter the peripheral circulation, where they would maintain persistent
infection. As these cells reenter secondary lymphoid tissue, the site where
they would most likely reencounter cognate antigen would be the tonsil.
This would provide a mechanism for preferential homing and reactivation
of the latently infected memory cells in the tonsil compared to other lymph
nodes. This hypothesis is made uncertain by the fact that EBV encodes latent
proteins, LMP1 and LMP2, which, respectively, can mimic CD40 and antigen
receptor-like signalsref1,
ref2.
This makes cells latently infected with EBV potentially independent of
T-cell help and/or antigen. The situation is further complicated by the
observation from in vitro studies that signaling through LMP1 and/or
LMP2 can block reactivation initiated by antigen receptor signalingref1,
ref2,
implying that the virus has encoded latent proteins with the specific intent
of blocking antigen-driven activation. This means that a cell destined
to replicate the virus cannot be expressing LMP1 and LMP2. This strongly
implicates the circulating resting memory cell, the only latently infected
cells type in which expression of these proteins is absent. Taken together,
this information leads to a model whereby reception of host-derived signals
by a resting latently infected memory cell in the tonsil leads to activation
and then terminal differentiation of the cell into a plasma cell without
turning on expression of the latent genes. Once the cell becomes a full-blown
plasma cell, viral replication begins. This model predicts that the BZLF1
promoter should be highly and specifically responsive to a plasma cell-specific
transcription factor(s). In vitro studies with the Akata cell line
appear at first glance to support the idea that antigen drives viral replication.
Cross-linking of the antigen receptor (BCR) on these cells leads to their
synchronous entry into the lytic cycle, and BCR signaling is known to be
important in plasma cell differentiationref.
However, a number of properties of this system suggest that it may not
be representative of in vivo replication. First and most striking
is that activation of the BZLF1 promoter in Akata cells occurs within minutes
of the antigen receptor signal, whereas differentiation into plasma cells
takes days. The response in Akata cells is too acute to be the same as
the in vivo mechanism, and not surprisingly, the Akata cells do
not undergo plasma cell differentiation prior to viral replication. The
Akata system may be more closely related to the spontaneous reactivation
that occurs when latently infected peripheral memory cells are placed into
cultureref.
This is an acute reactivation, presumably in response to the stress induced
upon being placed in culture, and also occurs too rapidly to be associated
with terminal differentiation. It is also important to note that all of
the signals that induce viral replication in vitro in cell lines,
including surface Ig cross-linking of Akata cells, are associated with
the induction of apoptosis in the cellsref.
However, expression of lytic EBV genes protects these cells from apoptosisref,
suggesting that EBV has acquired specific genes to save a stressed cell
from death while the virus replicates. This discussion raises the possibility
that there may be two mechanisms for reactivating EBV in vivo. One
may be an acute reactivation in resting memory cells in response to stress
that allows the virus to escape quickly before the cell dies. The other
allows replication of EBV in plasma cells located in the epithelium of
the tonsil. This allows for high-level production of virions that may be
shed directly into saliva. For the tonsils that we fractionated and studied
in detail, 10 to 20% of the infected plasma cells initiated viral replication.
We measured the frequencies of virus-infected cells in the unfractionated
tonsil lymphocytes and in the subsets isolated on the basis of CD38 expression.
Since we also know the relative abundance of plasma cells based on CD38
staining, we can use this information to estimate that 0.1 to 0.5% of all
of the infected cells in the tonsil are replicating the virus. Assuming
approximately 1010 B lymphocytes in Waldeyer's ring and a range
of infected cells from 1 to 1,000/107ref,
we may calculate that anywhere from 5 to 1,000 cells are replicating EBV
in Waldeyer's ring at any one time. However, we found sequentially fewer
cells expressing the immediate-early, early, and then late lytic antigens,
such that it appears that only 10% of the cells complete the replicative
cycle. This suggests that < 100 cells are actually releasing virus in
Waldeyer's ring at any given time. This may account for the relatively
low titers of EBV observed in the saliva of most healthy carriersref.
The sequential diminution in the numbers of cells replicating the virus
as they proceed through the cycle does not appear to be a technical artifact;
therefore, some physiological process is impeding the progress of the cells.
One possibility, as discussed above, is that replication in the majority
of cells is abortive and simply never reaches completion. An alternative
explanation for the diminution is that immunosurveillance by CTL kills
the cells as they progress through the lytic cycle, leaving fewer and fewer
cells as the cycle progresses. This is consistent with our finding that
the cells expressing BZLF1, a major target of CTL, do not down regulate
class I MHC and are therefore liable to CTL attack. It is possible that
MHC down regulation could occur at later times, since we analyzed only
immediate-early (i.e., BZLF1) expression; however, this presumably would
be too late, since the CTL would already have detected the cells expressing
the immediate-early genes. This distinguishes EBV from other herpesviruses,
such as HSV, which encode immediate-early proteins that specifically blunt
CTL responses by down regulating MHC class Iref.
The failure of EBV to do so may reflect different strategies for these
viruses. For HSV the strategy of the virus is to sporadically reactivate
and produce infectious virus for a brief period of time before viral replication
is shut down by the immune response. EBV, on the other hand, is chronically
shed into the saliva, so transient delay of the immune response would not
be useful. Rather, it appears that EBV is able to continue generating replicative
cells, a few of which complete the cycle despite the cellular immune response.
This suggests that EBV may have developed a mechanism to constitutively
reduce the local effectiveness of the CTL response, perhaps through the
production of viral IL-10 during the lytic cycleref1,
ref2.
In
a previous study on viral replication, we used Gardella gels to detect
the linear replicating form of viral DNAref.
In that study we failed to detect linear DNA in the IgD– fraction,
which would appear to be inconsistent with the present results. However,
the present study predicts that only very small numbers of plasma cells
reach the late stages of replication, and it would not be possible to load
sufficient cells on a Gardella gel to detect this very low level. Conversely,
in that study we did detect linear viral DNA in the CD19– fraction.
In follow-up studies we were unable to associate this linear DNA with a
particular cell type. It is possible that it could be due to epithelial
cells with replicating virus or cell debris-associated virion DNA from
dead cells. One confusion that resulted from this study was the observed
surface phenotype (CD20lo) of tonsil plasma cells. This arose
in part because plasma cells from the bone marrow are CD20–ref1,
ref2
and in part because some reviews state that tonsil plasma cells are also
CD20–ref.
However, our study and several previous studies show clearly that tonsil
plasma cells, unlike the bone marrow, continue to express CD20, albeit
at a reduced levelref1,
ref2,
ref3.
In conclusion, we have shown that differentiation to plasma cells is associated
with induction of the EBV lytic cycle in vivo. It now remains to
be discovered what the signals are that drive this differentiationref.
During acute infection with EBV, the peripheral blood fills up with latently
infected, resting memory B cells to the point where up to 50% of all the
memory cells may carry EBV. Despite this massive invasion of the memory
compartment, the virus remains tightly restricted to memory cells, such
that, in one donor, < 1 in 104 infected cells were found
in the naive compartment. Even during acute infection, EBV persistence
is tightly regulated. This result confirms the prediction that during the
early phase of infection, before cellular immunity is effective, there
is nothing to prevent amplification of the viral cycle of infection, differentiation,
and reactivation, causing the peripheral memory compartment to fill up
with latently infected cells. Subsequently, there is a rapid decline in
infected cells for the first few weeks that approximates the decay in the
CTL responses to viral replicative antigens. This phase is followed by
a slower decline that, even by 1 year, had not reached a steady state.
Therefore, EBV may approach but never reach a stable equilibriumref.
EBNA1 is required to maintain the viral genome but is not recognized by
cytotoxic T cells. Consequently, it was proposed that this expression pattern
was used by latently infected B cells in vivo. This would be the
site of long-term, persistent infection by the virus and, by implication,
the progenitor of BL. EBV persists in memory B cells in the peripheral
blood and that BL is a tumor of memory cells. However, a normal B cell
expressing EBNA1 alone has been elusive. Most infected cells in the blood
express no detectable latent mRNA or proteins. The exception is that when
infected cells divide they express EBNA1 only. This is the first detection
of the BL viral phenotype in a normal, infected B cell in vivo.
It suggests that BL may be a tumor of a latently infected memory B cell
that is stuck proliferating because it is a tumor and, therefore, constitutively
expressing only EBNA1ref.
sporadic BL affects both children and
adults. Only < 20% of BL cases occurring in Western countries
are HHV-4 / EBV-associated;
HHV-6
? O’Conor
GT, 411-17, ref2.
The terminal ileum and lymph nodes are the more commonly involved sites
in sporadic BLref1,
ref2.
AIDS-related BLPathology and
genetics: tumors of haematopoietic and lymphoid tissues. The World Health
Organisation classification of tumors. Jaffe ES, Harris NL, Stein H, et
al, eds. Lyon: IARC Press, 2001 : BL has frequently been reported
as a common neoplasm in HIV
infected patientsref,
although it is not known why BL is so common in HIV and not in other forms
of immunodepression. These lymphomas usually display an activation of c-myc
by chromosome translocations that show structural similarities to those
found in patients with sporadic BLref.
Nonetheless, most AIDS related BLs in Western countries are EBV negativeref,
whereas in Africa they are strongly associated with EBVref
Burkitt-like (BL-like)
lymphoma has been commonly applied to those tumours that have morphological
features intermediate between large cell lymphoma with centroblastic or
immunoblastic features and typical BL. The REAL classification gives BL-like
lymphoma provisional status, leaving the differential diagnosis between
BL and diffuse large B cell lymphoma
(DLBCL)
unresolvedref.
The oncologists recommended that the category of BL-like lymphoma be reserved
for tumours to be treated "like Burkitt lymphoma". A recent study by the
southwest oncology group (SWOG) concluded that BL-like lymphoma can be
recognised by its combined morphology and phenotypical features and that
it represents a high grade lymphoma much closer to BL than DLBCLref.
In the World Health Organisation (WHO) classification, BL-like lymphoma
is listed as a morphological variant of BL (atypical BL), in addition
to the 3 subcategories—endemic, sporadic, and immunodeficiency associated—proposed
to reflect the major clinical and genetic subtypes of this diseasePathology
and genetics: tumors of haematopoietic and lymphoid tissues. The World
Health Organisation classification of tumors. Jaffe ES, Harris NL, Stein
H, et al, eds. Lyon: IARC Press, 2001. In the WHO classification,
the definition of atypical BL is a lymphoma that have the genetic abnormality
and immunophenotype of BL, but has more pleiomorphism or larger cells
than classic BL, and has a proliferation fraction of > 90%. It is not
clear whether atypical BL is a biologically distinct entity or a morphologic
variant of BL. In children, Burkitt's and non-Burkitt's types probably
do not differ clinicallyref,
whereas in adults, most cases classified as non-Burkitt's lymphoma are
similar to DLBCLref
Pathogenesis of
HHV-4
/ EBV+
BL appears to involve the combined actions of virus-induced B cell proliferation
and
a chromosomal translocation in a single B cell which leads c-myc
protooncogene under the control of ...
=> overexpression have been identified in endemic and sporadic BL. However,
some not very strict associations between JH and DH
recombination have been identified at 14q32, with distant 5‘ c-myc recombination
in endemic cases of BL, whereas in sporadic cases Sµ and S recombination
was identifiedref
at 14q32, with near 5‘ or intronic c-myc recombination at 8q24. These differences
between endemic and sporadic BL do not mean that each of these subtypes
of lymphoma represents a perfectly homogeneous entityref.
Instead, it seems probable that BL is composed of a mixture of molecular
types and that the incidence of each subtype might depend upon environmental
factorsref1,
ref2.
Yet, the sporadic form of BL can also occur in endemic areasref,
as reported in the table below, which summarises the distribution of BL
collected from endemic areas of Kenya according to the age of patients,
the clinical pathological characteristics, and the EBV and HIV status.
These observations emphasise the importance of precise disease definition
for biological and epidemiological studies.
BL age under 16 years (range 2–16; median 6)
BL age over 16 years (range, 17–58; median 29)
Total cases
23
16
Male/Female
14/9
10/6
Site
jaw
16
2
nodal
3
7
ileum
2
5
other
2
2
HIV
0
8
EBV
21
12
The necessary cytogenetics for the diagnosis of BL should be the presence
of the t(8;14) (q24;q32) translocation and its variants, or c-myc rearrangement.
If cytogenetic or Southern blot cannot be applied to solid tumours the
most reasonable surrogate for c-myc rearrangement is probably the proliferation
fraction. Therefore, cases in which cytogenetic analysis is not available
should not be diagnosed as BL or BL-like without a Ki-67 fraction close
to 100%Pathology and genetics: tumors of haematopoietic and lymphoid
tissues. The World Health Organisation classification of tumors. Jaffe
ES, Harris NL, Stein H, et al, eds. Lyon: IARC Press, 2001. The morphological
similarity between BLs probably results from the fact that they all have
a common translocation, t(8;14), and consequent c-myc rearrangement and
overexpression. However, it is also true that BLs account for only 30%
of lymphomas bearing a c-myc translocation at presentationGaulard
Ph, Delsol G, Callat MP, et al. Cytogenetic and clinicopathologic features
of B-cell lymphomas associated with the Burkitt translocation t(8;14) (q24;q32)
or its variants. J Clin Pathol 2002; 55(suppl 1):A22. Furthermore,
the c-myc translocation is not the only genetic lesion found in BLref,
and myc transformed cells are usually characterised by the loss of expression
of several genesref.
Cooperating alterations of cell cycle associated genes probably contribute
to the pathogenesis of BLref1,
ref2.
The c-Myc oncoprotein promotes proliferation and apoptosis, such that mutations
that disable apoptotic programmes often cooperate with MYC during tumorigenesis
: 2 common mutant MYC alleles derived from human BL uncouple proliferation
from apoptosis and, as a result, are more effective than wild-type MYC
at promoting B cell lymphomagenesis in mice. Mutant MYC proteins retain
their ability to stimulate proliferation and activate p53, but are defective
at promoting apoptosis due to a failure to induce the BH3-only protein
Bim (a member of the Bcl2 family) and effectively inhibit Bcl2. Disruption
of apoptosis through enforced expression of Bcl2, or loss of either Bim
or p53 function, enables wild-type MYC to produce lymphomas as efficiently
as mutant MYC. These data show how parallel apoptotic pathways act together
to suppress MYC-induced transformation, and how mutant MYC proteins, by
selectively disabling a p53-independent pathway, enable tumour cells to
evade p53 action during lymphomagenesisref.
p53
mutations have been found in 30–40% of BL samplesref,
and most lymphomas with wild-type p53 might have lesions in other growth
suppressor genesref
recently, mutations of the nuclear localisation signal of the RBL2
/ p130
tumour suppressor gene have also been detected in BL cell lines and primary
tumoursref.
The pRb2/p130 tumour suppressor gene belongs to the retinoblastoma (Rb)
gene family, along with Rb and p107. Although they have similar functional
properties, Rb family members are not functionally redundant and each protein
has a different temporal profile of interaction with different E2F membersref1,
ref2,
ref3.
Whereas Rb is found in both quiescent and proliferating cells, the expression
of Rb2/p130 and p107 is related to the cell cycleref.
In an ideally controlled proliferating cell population with identical cell
cycle and cycle phase times, during which a given protein can be detected
in the nucleus by the corresponding antibody, the percentages of cells
expressing pRb2/p130 and p107 should be inversely correlatedref.
Although such a pattern of Rb2/p130 and p107 expression has been demonstrated
in different types of non-Hodgkin’s lymphomas, this is not the case in
BLsref.
The Rb2/p130 gene is mutated in most cases of endemic BL and to a lesser
extent in sporadic BL. In contrast, in AIDS related BL, the wild-type pRb2/p130
gene is highly expressedref1,
ref2.
In those tumours in which the Rb2/p130 gene is mutated, the interaction
between individual proteins and E2F family members and the timing of formation
of particular protein–E2F complexes during the cell cycle can be deregulated.25
In addition to mutations of the gene, interaction with viral oncoproteins
is another important mechanism of pRb2/p130 inactivationref1,
ref2.
pRb2/p130 shares, with all members of the retinoblastoma gene family, the
ability to interact physically with certain DNA virus oncoproteins; by
this mechanism, pRb2/p130 is inactivated yet maintained in its underphosphorylated
formref1,
ref2,
ref3,
ref4,
ref5.
Thus, the absence of mutations in the Rb2/p130 gene and the unusually high
expression of pRb2/p130 in tumours with high proliferative activity, such
as AIDS related BL, may suggest a physical interaction of pRb2/p130 with
viral products. Although HIV-1 has long been recognised as the aetiological
agent of AIDS, the role of HIV-1 as an oncogenic virus has not yet been
well established. Data exist that clearly suggest that the HIV gene product
Tat can contribute to the growth and oncogenesis of human and animal cellsref.
Soluble Tat can function as a biologically active extracellular protein
released by infected cells and readily taken up by uninfected cells.36,37
This has also been shown to occur in AIDS related B cell lymphomas, by
the diffuse and nuclear staining seen in tissue sections immunostained
with anti-Tat monoclonal antibodyref.
In addition, there is experimental evidence that extracellular Tat acts
directly on B cellsref.
In particular, germinal centre B cell proliferation was enhanced by the
addition of Tat at the initiation of the culture, suggesting that Tat acts
on the early stage of B cell activation, probably before the G1
to S phase transitionref.
This is in line with new data indicating that the well established function
of Rb2/p130 in the control of the G0/G1 transition
can be inactivated by physical interaction with the Tat protein of HIV-1.
In fact, the results of an in vitro and in vivo binding assay
suggest that the Tat protein of HIV-1 is one of those viral oncoproteins
that interact with the Rb family. In particular, they revealed that the
Tat protein of HIV-1 interacts specifically with the pocket region of the
Rb2/p130 proteinref.
This can result in the inactivation of Rb2/p130 oncosuppressive properties
and the induction of genes needed to proceed through the cell cycle including
p107, cyclin A, and cyclin Bref.
Consequently, some B cell clones among a virus induced B cell proliferation
might have an uninterrupted cell cycle and a growth advantage, thus favouring
the incidence of B cell malignancies in lymphoid organs of HIV-1 positive
patients. Increased cell proliferation has been shown to account almost
entirely for tumour prevalence in immunocompromised patientsref.
Spontaneous regression of HIV-1 associated lymphoproliferative disorders
has been reported after highly active antiretroviral therapyref1,
ref2,
ref3.
In quiescent G0 cells, the nuclear E2F–pRb2/p130 complex is
responsible for the active repression of several cellular promoters. After
its release into the cell cycle, pRb2/p130 is phosphorylated by G1 cyclin
dependent kinases (cdks) and subsequently degraded through a proteosome
dependent mechanism, resulting in the derepression of a variety of genes,
including p107. The accumulated p107 protein is then able to interact with
E2F4 and E2F5, which have been released from pRb2/p130, and associate with
cyclin A (cyc A)/cdk2.
Expression of the TCL-1 oncogene in EBV+ BL tumour cells is
dependent on the presence of EBV. This finding suggests that the ability
of EBV to induce TCL-1 would circumvent the need for the additional genetic
or epigenetic changes that lead to the constitutive expression of this
oncogene in EBV-negative BL tumoursref.
Differential
diagnosis : the distinction between BL and diffuse
large-B-cell lymphoma
is not reliably reproducible with the use of the current criteria of morphology,
immunophenotype, and genetic abnormalities : the characteristic t(8;14)
translocation of Burkitt's lymphoma also occurs in 5-10% of cases of DLBCLref.
Because DLBCL is > 20 times as common as BLref,
a lymphoma with a t(8;14) translocation can present a diagnostic problem.
Agreement among expert hematopathologists on the pathological diagnosis
of classic Burkitt's lymphoma, atypical Burkitt's lymphoma, and diffuse
large-B-cell lymphomas is only 53%ref
(Magrath I, Jaffe ES, Bhatia K. Burkitt's lymphoma. In: Knowles DM, ed.
Neoplastic hematopathology. Philadelphia: Lippincott Williams & Wilkins,
2001:953-86). The Burkitt's translocation or its variants, which juxtapose
the locus of the myc oncogene and one of the three immunoglobulin (IG)
loci, are present in almost all Burkitt's lymphomasref1,
ref2.
Nevertheless, myc translocations are not specific for BL since they also
occur in other lymphomas, including DLBCL. In the latter, chromosomal breakpoints
at the myc locus are recurrently associated with non-IG partner loci and
complex chromosomal alterationsref1,
ref2,
ref3,
ref4,
ref5,
ref6,
ref7,
ref8.
The imprecise distinction between BL and DLBCL on diagnosis may lead to
the inadequate treatment of some patients with a mature aggressive B-cell
lymphoma. A molecular signature consisting of 58 genes, including
several target genes of the nuclear factor-B pathway (i.e., BCL2A1, FLIP,
CD44, NFKBIA, BCL3, and STAT3) that are known to distinguish ABC–like or
GCB-cell–like lymphomasref1,
ref2,
allows differentiation of BL (mBL) and DLBCLref.
The mBL signature extends the WHO definition of Burkitt's lymphoma to cases
with the morphologic characteristics of DLBCL and expression of BCL2. Yet
not all cases with morphologic or immunophenotypical features of BL were
classified as mBL.
It is notable that these genes were expressed at lower levels in mBL
cases than in cases of GCB-cell–like DLBCL. 3 main cytogenetic groups can
be distinguished within the mature aggressive B-cell lymphomas :
"myc-simple": lymphomas with IG-myc fusions and a low chromosomal complexity
score (<6) that do not have IGH-BCL2 fusions and BCL6 breakpoints.
"myc-complex": all lymphomas with non–IG-myc fusions or all lymphomas with
IG-myc fusions that have a high chromosomal complexity score (6), an IGH-BCL2
fusion, or BCL6 breakpoint, or any combination of these
The mBL group predominantly consisted of myc-simple lymphomas; the non-mBL
group predominantly consisted of myc-negative lymphomas. In contrast, the
intermediate group contained most of the myc-complex cases but also occasional
myc-simple and several myc-negative cases. Hierarchical clustering revealed
four prominent clusters of coordinately expressed genes, which we term
gene-expression "signatures," because they reflect specific biologic processesref
:
c-myc protein and its target genes constituted one signature, which was
more highly expressed in Burkitt's lymphoma than in DLBCL
the second signature included genes that were expressed in normal germinal-center
B cells. The subgroup of these genes that was expressed more highly in
BL than in GCB-cell–like DLBCL is termed the "BL-high" signature.
The third and fourth signatures were expressed at lower levels in BL than
in DLBCLref.
The microarray method seems to outperform the expert pathologists:
17%ref
and 34%ref
of cases with the gene-expression signature of Burkitt's lymphoma had been
called DLBCL or unclassifiable high-grade B-cell lymphoma; 0.4%ref
and 4%ref
of cases without the Burkitt's signature had been called classic or atypical
BL; and 3%ref
and 8%ref
of cases diagnosed as DLBCL or unclassifiable high-grade B-cell lymphoma
had a BL.
Though BL and GCB-cell–like DLBCL both originate from GC B cellsref1,
ref2,
the expression of a subgroup of GC B-cell genes distinguished BL from DLBCL.
NF-kB target genes were expressed at lower levels
in BL than in any of the DLBCL subgroups; it is unclear whether this is
due to differences in the malignant cells or in the tumor-infiltrating
immune cells. BL tumors expressed MHC class I genes at very low levels
as compared with tumors of DLBCL. Previous studies have documented the
loss of MHC class I molecules in some cell lines derived from BL (Voltz
R, Jilg W, Wolf H. Modification of HLA expression as a possible factor
in the pathogenesis of Burkitt's lymphoma. Hamatol Bluttransfus 1989;32:289-292),
but the mechanism underlying this down-modulation is unclear. Cases
with both the t(8;14) and t(14;18) translocations are very aggressive and
associated with a poor prognosisref.
cytomorphology : Burkitt’s tumours are composed of monomorphic, medium
sized cells (smaller than the cells of most DLBCL) with round nuclei, multiple
nucleoli, and relatively abundant basophilic cytoplasm, which may give
the cells a "cohesive appearance". Typical morphological pattern of Burkitt’s
lymphoma (Giemsa stained; original magnification, x375).
These tumours have an extremely high rate of proliferation,
in addition to a high rate of apoptosis. A "starry sky" pattern
is usually present, imparted by numerous benign macrophages that have ingested
apoptotic tumour cells. These features are distinctive, but they overlap
with morphologic and genetic attributes of DLBCL. BL may have an admixture
of large lymphoid cells, and DLBCL may have medium-sized cells, a high
proliferation fraction, a starry-sky pattern, and even a c-myc rearrangement.
Based on Ig gene rearrangement studies, the cell of origin of BL is
currently thought to be a germinal
centre B cellref,
although several studies of IgHV genes in BLs suggest that they may derive
from memory
B cells
rather than germinal centre B cellsref.
However, most of these studies rely on cell lines or a small series of
cases. Endemic and AIDS-related forms showed a considerably higher VH
mutation rate than the sporadic form (5.1%, 5.4% and 1.5% respectively).
The mutations in eBL and AIDS-related BL also showed signs of antigen selection,
while no signs of antigen selection were found in sBL. Finally, after subcloning
the amplificates, sequence analysis revealed no signs of ongoing mutations
in any of the cases analyzed. Since one of the main differences between
eBL and AIDS related BL on the one hand and sBL on the other hand is the
association with EBV, we compared EBV-positive and EBV-negative BL, independently
of their geographical origin and HIV status. The differences in the number
of somatic mutations and antigen selection were even more evident when
this approach was used. EBV+ and EBV- BL may originate
from 2 distinct subsets of B cells, pointing to a particular role for the
GC reaction in the pathogenesis of these tumors. The different types of
C-MYC translocation reported in BL may also be related to the different
stages of B-cell maturationref.
What are the immediate implications of these studies for clinical practice?
RNA extraction and microarray analysis are laborious and expensive and
are therefore not ready for real-time diagnosis in clinical practice, but
other tools that are currently available to pathologists can be used to
identify some of the distinguishing features of cases with the molecular
signature of BL :
morphologic features
proliferation fraction (Ki-67) (%)
translocation
immunophenotype
myc
other
standard
future
features suggestive of BL
medium-sized cells
> 95%
Ig-myc
none
CD10+
BCL6+
BCL2-
CD44-
MUM1-
TCL1+
HLA-I-
CD23-
cyclin H-
features not suggestive of BL
large cells
< 90%
myc-negative
non-IG-MYC
BCL2
BCL6
CD10-
BCL6-
BCL2+
CD44+
MUM1+
TCL1-
HLA-I+
CD23+
cyclin H+
Both the gene-expression signatureref
and the immunophenotyperef
of lymphomas with the Burkitt's signature reflect the germinal-center stage
of B-cell differentiation. Markers of germinal-center and non–germinal-center
B cells can be detected by routine immunohistochemical analysis. IGH, IGL,
myc, BCL2, and BCL6 rearrangements can be detected by FISH in paraffin
sections. New markers could be used in practice: down-regulation of class
I HLA antigens and CD44 and up-regulation of TCL1 in Burkitt's lymphoma;
other immunophenotypic markers have been suggested recently as wellref1,
ref2,
ref3,
ref4
Therapy :
with the use of chemotherapy regimens that involve methotrexate and cytarabine,
cure rates for sporadic Burkitt's lymphoma approach 90% in children and
70% in adultsref
CHOP-like regimens (CHOPref
or CNOPref).
Adults with Burkitt's lymphoma benefit from the aggressive treatment designed
for childrenref,
but they often do not tolerate very well the side effects of intensive
chemotherapy.
intensive regimens (Berlin–Frankfurt–Münsterref;
cyclophosphamide, doxorubicin, high-dose methotrexate or ifosfamide, etoposide,
and high-dose cytarabine4; or intensive chemotherapy regimens combined
with autologous stem-cell transplantation).
R-hyperCVAD
: rituximab 375 mg/m2 was given on days 1 and 11 of hyper-CVAD
courses and on days 1 and 8 of methotrexate and cytarabine courses. CR
was achieved in 24 of 28 (86%) evaluable patients; 3 had a partial response,
and 1 had resistant disease. There were no induction deaths. The 3-year
OS, EFS, and DFS rates were 89%, 80%, and 88%, respectively. 9 elderly
patients achieved CR with all of them in continuous CR (except 1 death
in CR from infection), with a 3-year OS rate of 89%. Multivariate analysis
of current and historical (those treated with hyper-CVAD alone) groups
identified age and treatment with rituximab as favorable factorsref