-
hyponeocytosis : leukopenia
with immature forms of leukocytes present in the blood
-
hypo-orthocytosis : leukopenia
in which the proportion of the various forms of leukocytes is normal
-
lymphocytes (lymphopenia / lymphocytopenia
(< 1.5 . 103 / mL in
adults or < 3 . 103 / µL in children <
2 yr))
Aetiology :
-
sarcoidosis

-
systemic
lupus erythematosus (SLE)

-
autoimmune lymphopenia

-
immunodeficiencies

-
Salmonella typhi

-
influenzavirus

-
B lymphopenia
-
T lymphopenia : apoptosis of T lymphocytes
in
vitro, linked to transient T cell loss in vivo, is a consequence
of certain viral infections, including lymphocytic choriomeningitisref
and vacciniaref
in mice and EBVref
in humans. It has also been reported in association with HIV-1ref1,
ref2
in humans, although whether or not direct HIV infection is required for
this effect, and its specificity for CD4+ T cells, are subjects
of debateref
Aetiology :
-
thoracoscopic
talc poudrage
ref.
-
CD4+ lymphopenia
Aetiology :
-
neoplasia
-
HIV-1

-
type
II BLS / class II MHC deficiency

-
idiopathic CD4+
lymphocytopenia (ICL) / severe unexplained HIV-seronegative immune suppression
(SUHIS) : CD4+ count <300 cells/ml
or a CD4+ count that is <20% of the total T cell count on
2 occasions, with no evidence of retroviral infections (HIV-1
or -2, HTLV-1 or -2) on testing, and absence of any defined immunodeficiency
or therapy that depresses the levels of CD4+ T cells (unaccompanied
by increased CD8+ T lymphocytes and hypergammaglobulinemia)
either alone (ICL according to CDC, 1992ref)
or accompanied by clinical signs and symptoms of cellular immune deficiency
(SUHIS according to WHOref).
Cases have been identified since 1983ref.
It is likely that others could have been identified much earlier; however,
the determination of CD4+ T-cell counts has been routine only
since the early to mid-1980s and the beginning of the HIV epidemic. ICL
differs from HIV infection by stable levels of CD4+ T cell
counts in contrast to the progressive loss of this subpopulation observed
in the course of HIV diseaseref1,
ref2,
ref3.
Anyway recently a subset of ICL patients mimicking HIV disease has been
reported: severe, prolonged decrement in peripheral CD4+ T cells
with progressive decline in such counts documented in some; CD4/CD8
T cell ratios <= 1; and a history of opportunistic infectionsref1,
ref2.
Moreover, a great heterogeneity in the symptomatology and the T cell
phenotypic abnormalities have been reported among patients with ICL.
Epidemiology : 0.5–2% of adultsref1,
ref2,
ref3.
30% of the patients are women, as compared with 11% among those with HIV-1
in the USA
Aetiology :
-
although Laurence et al.ref
and Gupta et al.ref
suggested in 1992 that ICL could be due to a new retrovirus distinct from
HIV-1 and HIV-2 (a human intracisternal A-type retrovirus, HIAP-II, was
detected in a subset of patients with ICL : most of them were also ANA
positiveref),
epidemiologic studies showed no evidence for a transmissible agent
: all close contacts and sexual partners who were studied were clinically
well, including 31 sexual partnersref1,
ref2,
ref3
in whom serologic, immunologic, and virologic studies for HIV were negative.
Indeed, ICL can be diagnosed with the onset of opportunistic infections
or among autoimmune disorders, whereas it remains asymptomatic in other
patientsref1,
ref2,
ref3,
ref4.
In addition to the CD4+ lymphocytopenia, several patients
also display a CD8+ lymphocytopenia while low B or NK cell counts
have also been reported in othersref1,
ref2,
ref3.
The heterogeneity of ICL does not favor the hypothesis of a unique causeref
(Moore, J. P. and Ho, D. D. 1992. HIV-negative AIDS. Lancet 340:475). CD4
cell counts of < 500 cells/ml were, however,
associated with subsequent HIV seroconversionref.
A subset of patients has anyway antibodies against retroviral proteins
and nuclear antigensref
. Low CD4+ counts are rare among anti-HIV-1-negative volunteer
blood donors and are generally associated with transient illnesses. If
any unknown virus progresses similarly to HIV-1, CD4+ count
donor screening would be a poor surrogate for its detectionref.
There is also no epidemiologic evidence to suggest that a transmissible
microbe is involved. The cases of idiopathic CD4+ T-lymphocytopenia
were widely dispersed, with no clustering.
-
some authors have suggested ICL to be classified among common
variable immunodeficiency
ref.
Similarly, a case of ICL associated with recurrent opportunistic infections
could be attributed to a primary immunodeficiency disorderref
-
ICL was found in 16% of anti-SSA seropositive primary Sjogren's
syndrome
patientsref.
Anti-CD4 antibodies were observed more frequently in patients with Sjögren's
syndrome (12.6%) as compared with the control groups (0.6%), and at a level
similar to that seen among the HIV-1 patients (13.0%). However, no correlation
was found between the presence of anti-CD4 antibodies and CD4+ T lymphocytopenia
in the Sjögren patientsref.
-
2 familial cases have been reportedref1,
ref2
-
a recent study of "normal" persons reported a substantial proportion of
subjects with CD4+ T lymphocytopenia, suggesting that this condition
may occur as a result of the inherent variability in the measurement of
T lymphocyte subsetsref
-
it is hypothesised that CD4+ T lymphocytopenia represents the
tail end of natural statistical variation in CD4+ cell countsref
Pathogenesis : increased spontaneous and
activation-induced apoptosis was associated with enhanced expression
of Fas and FasL in unstimulated cell populations, and partially inhibited
by soluble anti-Fas mAbref.
Antihistone
autoantibodies, presumably induced by fragmented chromatin, were detected
in some of these sera, with reactivity predominantly to type H2B, a pattern
identical to that found in HIV diseaseref1,
ref2
and SIV infection in macaquesref,
both of which have been associated with CD4+ T cell apoptosis:
in vitro in the case of HIVref1,
ref2,
and in vivo in macaquesref.
Alternatively, other studies reported proliferative T cell defects to
mitogens or antigens in patients with ICL and opportunistic infectionsref1,
ref2,
ref3,
ref4.
Major reduction of the proliferative response to CD3-TCR stimulation that
affected only the depleted T-cell subpopulationref.
Abnormality
of the PTK p56Lck in CD8+ T cells might play
a role : a full-length p56Lck was expressed in T lymphocytes
which rather displayed a 50% decrease in autophosphorylation and in in
vitro kinase activity. This observation contrasted with the conserved protein
tyrosine phosphorylation process induced by CD3 triggering in the patient's
CD4+ and CD8+ T cellsref.
In HIV patients a CD4+ T cell proliferation deficiency is associated
with an impaired CD3-induced tyrosine phosphorylation process, and altered
levels of p56Lck and p59Fynref1,
ref2,
ref3,
ref4.
Symptoms & signs : the CD4 deficit
in these patients is not associated with other cellular and/or humoral
immunological anomalies and the clinical manifestations, essentially of
scant importance, have not shown signs of progression towards severe immunodeficiency
syndromes. Anyway severe ICL predisposes to the same opportunistic infections
as AIDS :
-
dementia and encephalopathyref
-
viral infections :
-
3 cases of PML
have been reported in ICLref1,
ref2,
ref3
-
EBV and CMV coinfection of the central nervous systemref
-
empyema thoracis and cytomegaloviral retinitisref
-
cutaneous infections by papillomavirus, relapsing generalized herpes zosterref
and Candida albicansref
-
juvenile laryngeal papillomatosis (JLP)ref
-
bacterial infections :
-
chronic mucocutaneous candidiasis (CMC), recurrent abscesses, and relapsing
aphthous and ulcerous lesions. In addition to ICL the patient frequently
showed a panlymphocytopenia. An increased percentage of gd+
T lymphocytes and IgD+ IgM+ B lymphocytes, and a
decreased percentage of CD21+ B lymphocytes, were observed.
In
vitro assays showed normal T-cell responses to candidin and T-cell
mitogens, but impaired B-cell responses to PWM. B-cell maturation after
stimulation with Staphylococcus aureus Cowan I (SAC) and IL-2 was
nearly normalref.
-
chronic severe mycobacterial diseaseref
and disseminated infection with Mycobacterium aviumref
-
fungal infections :
-
pleural effusion due to Histoplasma capsulatumref1,
ref2
-
cryptococcal infections :
-
pulmonary cryptococcosis and lung cancerref
-
cryptococcal meningitisref1,
ref2,
ref3
-
recurrent oral candidiasis who subsequently developed cryptococcal meningitisref
-
active intestinal tuberculosis with esophageal candidiasisref
-
episodic erythematous candidiasis, persistent angular cheilitis, lingua
exfoliativa areata, and teleangiectasia of facial skin and buccal mucosaref
-
Pneumocystis carinii and Hemophillus influenzae pneumoniaref
-
protozoal infections :
-
cancers : 6 cases with NHL, including 1 with primary leptomeningeal lymphomaref
-
epilepsyref
-
intracranial haemorrhageref
Association with selective
IgA deficiency
has been reportedref
Therapy : weekly subcutaneous polyethylene
glycol (PEG)-IL-2
injections 50 000 U/m2 for 5.5 yearsref1,
ref2
and antimicrobials
ref
Prognosis : ICL patients have a longer
survival time than AIDS cases without HAART
-
CD8+ lymphopenia
Aetiology :
Analytic variability : the temperature of the specimen in transit, the
type of anticoagulant used, and the delay in analysis are of some importanceref
[9]; however, the major source of analytic variability is the actual phenotype
measurement, which is typically done using murine monoclonal antibodies
and flow cytometric analysis. Absolute subset values are a product of three
components: the total leukocyte count, the lymphocyte differential, and
the percentage of CD3+ T lymphocytes that express membrane CD4
or CD8. Published guidelines have minimized technical difficulties, including
problems of coexpression of CD4 and CD8, contamination of preparations
by CD4+ but CD3- non-T cells, and genetic polymorphisms
among lymphocyte antigenic determinantsref
[9]. No mandatory standards exist, however, for immunophenotyping by flow
cytometric analysis, and limited information is available on the degree
of interlaboratory variability. Indeed, both analytic and biologic variability
exist in all three test components. One quality assessment found that no
technical change related to instrument, monoclonal antibody, or fluorochrome
label would significantly improve interlaboratory agreement on CD4 measurementsref
[10]. Yet, it is heartening that a recent multicenter proficiency test
of 13 laboratories found that the analytic variability for the percentage
and absolute number of CD4+ T cells using specimens from normal
controls was 4.1% and 8.4%, respectively, compared with values of 6% and
29.4%, respectively, measured 4 years previouslyref
[9].
Biological variability may be even greater in magnitude than analytic
variability. First, circannual (seasonal) rhythms may occur, with a 13%
change from week to week in total lymphocyte countsref
[11] and with substantial alteration in absolute CD4 and CD8 counts from
month to monthref
[12]. No such variability was seen in the CD4:CD8 ratio or in the total
number of CD3+ T lymphocytesref
[12], however, and persons maintained a fixed, discrete range of CD4 values
when followed for periods of 2ref
[13] or 5ref
[14] years, even among those with initial values < 300/mm3. Other quantifiable
factors that can influence these cell populations include age, sex, ethnic
origin, circadian rhythm, physical and psychological stresses, drugs (such
as zidovudine, cephalosporins, cancer chemotherapeutic agents, nicotine,
adrenal and gonadal steroids), antilymphocyte autoantibodies, and splenectomy
[7, 9, 15, 16] (Table 1). Sex need not be taken into account when assessing
CD8 counts. In one study, however, the mean CD4 percentages were greater
for women than for men by 3.5% (P = 0.0001), and the CD4:CD8 ratio was
0.17 units greater for women than for menref
[17]. Age also does not affect CD8 values, but an increase of 1.1% per
decade occurs in the percentage of CD4+ cells, and a 0.09-unit-per-decade
increase in CD4:CD8 ratio in persons older than 20 yearsref
[17]. Without appropriate correction, as many as 10% of elderly patients
(>70 years) would be classified as having values higher than published
"normal ranges"ref
[17].
Effect of psychological and physical stressors and splenectomy on T-cell
subpopulations :
Standard values for T-cell subsets have been generated using a Monte
Carlo procedure for nongaussian distribution and the best-fit distribution
of each parameterref
[17]. However, the literature offers contradictory assessments, usually
based on small samples. For example, although most studies have described
age-associated increases in the percentage of CD4+ T cells with
no effect on CD8 values, a few noted decreases in the percentage of CD8+
cellsref1,
ref2,
ref3
[18-20]. Some studies have reported that the absolute number of CD4+
T cells remains stable with advancing ageref
[20], whereas others have shown a decline as lymphocytes constitute a lower
percentage of peripheral leukocytesref
[19]. In one large survey of adolescents between ages 11 and 16 years,
absolute counts did not differ from adult valuesref
[14]. In addition, the inclusion of heterosexual women did not statistically
affect the overall mean values for the various subsetsref
[14]. An earlier report supported these basic tenets, except for the fact
that the "adult pattern" of CD4 counts and CD4:CD8 ratios was not seen
in adolescents between ages 12 and 16 yearsref
[21]. It should also be recognized that some blacks and Asians may lack
or be heterozygous for one CD4 epitope, defined by the OKT4A monoclonal
antibody, but not by the Leu-3a reagentref1,
ref2
[4, 18]. Otherwise, race does not appear to significantly influence CD4
or CD8 determinations, at least in the absence of physiologic lymphopeniaref1,
ref2
[18, 21].
Proper accounting of these variables is important in evaluating an
individual patient, although these factors are unlikely to lead to a diagnosis
of ICL/SUHIS or to be associated with a progressive decrease in any cell
population. Biologic variability due to diurnal rhythms may be of greater
significance, however. From a nadir at approximately 12:30 hours, CD4 and
CD8 counts increase to a peak at about 20:30, whereas CD3 counts reach
a zenith somewhat later, at 4:30ref1,
ref2
[22, 23]. The increment in absolute CD4 counts can be as high as a cumulative
60%ref
[22]. Many laboratories recommend that serial T-cell subset analyses be
done on blood samples taken at a standard time of the dayref
[22], but this admonition is rarely addressed in clinical practice or in
small studies. Although these changes persist in HIV-positive persons,
their magnitude is greatly attenuated [22]. The physiology of this response
is unclear, given that neither the circadian organization of steroid secretion
from the adrenal cortex nor testis appears to correlate with the 12-hour
harmonic of T-lymphocyte circulationref
[23]. Circadian fluctuations in growth hormone may play a role. Changes
in T-cell subsets might also be expected in association with the menstrual
cycle, but such alterations have not yet been well documented. Changes
linked to pregnancy are noted below.
Effects of Pharmacologic, Psychological, and Physical Stressors : changes
in T-cell subsets may result from the exogenous administration of adrenal
or gonadal steroids. Acute glucocorticoid treatment of three volunteers
led to suppression of both CD4 and CD8 counts, from a baseline of 920 ±
33 and 510 ± 31, respectively, to 270 ± 4 and 240 ±
0.14 (mean ± SE), respectively, with a return to normal values within
48 hoursref
[24]. These changes were probably secondary to redistribution of leukocytes
among the periphery, bone marrow, lymph node, and spleen, with a decreased
efflux from lymphoid organsref
[25]. Chronic changes secondary to long-term steroid use are less dramaticref
[26] and must be distinguished from the disease process that prompted use
of the drug.
Transient changes may also be seen after severe physical or psychological
stress. In one study of 15 healthy personsref
[27], cognitive stressors caused elevations in heart rate and blood pressure,
without affecting serum cortisol or catecholamine levels or absolute T-lymphocyte
subsets (Table 1). Physical stress (ergometry), leading to elevation in
heart rate, blood pressure, and serum adrenaline and noradrenaline, has
been associated with a concomitant increase in the absolute number of CD8+
T cells relative to CD4+ T cells, resulting in a decrease in
the CD4:CD8 ratio (Table 1). Splenectomy has also been linked to a stable
increase in the percentage, but not the absolute count, of CD4+
cells; an increase in absolute CD8+ cells; and a decrease in
the CD4:CD8 ratio Table 1ref
[28].
Other medical conditions accompanied by severe stress may have immediate
effects on peripheral T-cell subsets without long-lasting sequelae. The
most dramatic changes have been reported after acute myocardial infarction.
In one studyref
[29], although absolute CD4 and CD8 counts did not differ statistically
between infarct and control groups, a decrease in CD4:CD8 ratios was noted
among infarct patients, with these low values typically persisting for
3 or more days after the event. The CD4:CD8 ratios among the 11 infarct
patients (0.83 ± 0.43) differed from both control (2.12 ±
1.13, P = 0.001) and acute sepsis cases (1.76 ± 1.05, P = 0.004);
however, no statistical difference was seen in ratios between the control
and acute sepsis groups [29].
Ranges for T-Lymphocyte Subsets in "Normal Controls"
Table 2 shows studies of unselected, asymptomatic adults that provided
means, standard deviations, and ranges or 95% CIs for absolute CD4 and
CD8 counts. All but three included screening for HIV-1 infection by enzyme-linked
immunosorbent assay (ELISA). The largest studiesref1,
ref2,
ref3
[14, 30, 31] specified that attention was paid to the time of day at which
blood was drawn, with duplicate determinations and quality control measures
in place; all participants were HIV seronegative. The smaller studies usually
did not provide specific information about analytic or biologic variables
for controls; these data are included for comparison with the more established
normal ranges and as specific controls for the studies listed in Tables
3 and 4. (When HIV serologies were not done in these latter instances,
a notation has been included in the appropriate table.) Companion data
are given for HIV-seronegative pregnant women as well as for HIV-seronegative
controls from the two major risk groups for HIV infection: homosexual men
and intravenous drug abusers.
Miscellaneous conditions associated with changes in T-lymphocyte subsets
:
The means for CD4+ and CD8+ T-cell counts presented
in each of these reports are remarkably similar, despite differences in
sex and the broad age groups included as adults. In one studyref
[14], a small number of these ostensibly healthy persons had stable but
very low CD4 counts during a 5-year period, technically fulfilling the
criteria for idiopathic CD4+ T lymphocytopenia. Clearly, other
phenomena must be considered when evaluating CD4+ T-cell counts
below the lowest limits of normal. The homeostatic control of peripheral
T lymphocytes is susceptible to the various internal and environmental
influences described above and conditioned by circulating hormones, cytokines,
and other lymphocyte productsref
[46]. In addition, the total number of peripheral T cells appears to be
independent of cellular input. In experimental systems, in the absence
of either the CD4+ or CD8+ T-cell population, cell
loss is routinely compensated for by the remaining subsetref
[46]. This phenomenon is also seen in patients with HIV, given that throughout
much of the clinical course the total T-cell levels (CD3+) remain
constant in the face of declining CD4 cells, secondary to CD8+
T lymphocytosisref
[47]. Regulation of these T-cell populations is rapid and flexible, adapting
to environmental changes through selection and amplification of appropriate
T-lymphocyte clonal specificities. In adults, T cells are replaced primarily
by cell proliferation at the periphery. Although > 30% of such cells are
renewed every 3 days, total numbers are relatively fixed, with lymphocytes
at varying stages of differentiation having different probabilities of
survival, modulated by the environmentref
[46]. Evaluation of T-cell population kinetics, with documentation of stability
in absolute values and attention to the subset ratio, is thus important
in defining "normal" fluctuations in T-cell counts. Unlike HIV, which involves
a progressive decline in CD4 counts that is typically accompanied by a
depressed CD4:CD8 ratio, combined changes of "physiologic" CD4+
T lymphopenia (low CD4 percentage and absolute counts <400/ml),
and an inverted ratio occurred in only 0.6% of 500 persons enrolled in
one large studyref
[14], and even these markedly depressed values were stable during a 5-year
period. This observation has been supported by other studies: only 1 of
275 healthy blood donors had a CD4 count < 300/ml
(CD4:CD8 ratio not reported)ref
[48], and none of 2284 HIV-seronegative homosexual men had CD4 counts of
less than 300/ml with multiple determinations
during a 10-year periodref
[49]. It has been suggested that such persons with an absolute CD4 count
physiologically "set" significantly below the means outlined in Table 2,
if infected with HIV, might be expected to progress to a clinical definition
of the AIDS at a more rapid rate than a patient whose baseline CD4 counts
were significantly greater than the meanref
[13]. Some anecdotal data support this contentionref
[50], but no evidence exists that these persons are otherwise compromised
immunologically. Unless long-term stability of CD4 counts < 95% CI and
CD4:CD8 ratios > 1.0 are documented, such persons with low CD4 cell counts
warrant further evaluation. Indeed, before the identification of HIV-1
and HIV-2 as the primary etiologic agents of AIDS, the possibility of segregating
healthy homosexual men from those at potential risk for disease, using
a combination of depressed absolute CD4 counts and CD4:CD8 ratio, was suggestedref
[34]. One blood center even conducted a T-lymphocyte subset analysis as
an interim screening procedure for a putative "AIDS agent"ref
[51]. Nearly 2% of 8715 consecutive volunteer blood donors between 17 and
77 years old had CD4:CD8 ratios < 0.85, and blood from these persons
was not used for clinical purposes. Most had concomitant low CD4 values,
and follow-up showed that some belonged to AIDS risk populations, despite
denials at the time of donationref
[51]. Other studies examining persons at high risk for HIV who were repeatedly
seronegative for HIV by ELISA and immunoblotting but who had HIV-1 proviral
DNA detectable by polymerase chain reactionref1,
ref2
[35, 52], support the use of CD4 counts in conjunction with the CD4:CD8
ratio. Similarly, among male homosexual couples discordant for HIV-1 antibodies,
those without evidence for HIV infection by polymerase chain reaction amplification
of proviral DNA had stable CD4+ T-cell counts and CD4:CD8 ratios
> 1, regardless of the absolute number of cells in these subsetsref
[53]. This finding further supports our recommendation that all persons
with a CD4 count < 400/ml and a CD4:CD8 ratio
< 1.0 should be investigated for HIV, as well as for other causes of
immune deficiency, and that the definition of ICL/SUHIS be restricted to
patients with < 300 to 400 CD4+ cells/ml,
an inverted ratio, and evidence of a progressive decline in CD4+
cells. A similar approach, together with the aggressive tracing of donors
and recipients, has been recommended within the transfusion community to
investigate cases of idiopathic CD4+ T lymphocytopeniaref
[54] and is further discussed here.
T-lymphocyte subsets in infectious disease : as reported in Table 3,
common pathogenic and opportunistic bacterial, viral, parasitic, and fungal
diseases can cause transient alterations in T-lymphocyte subsets. These
changes may be superimposed on various functional immune defects associated
with such infectionsref
[68] as well as on ill-defined syndromes of putative infectious etiology
sometimes linked to decrements in CD4 counts, such as the chronic fatigue
syndromeref
[69]. Even immunizations may affect absolute numbers of T-cell subsets,
transiently but significantly depressing CD4:CD8 ratios to < 1.0 in
25% of cases in one studyref
[70]. 2 risk factors for HIV, intravenous drug abuse (see Table 2) and
clotting disorders (see Table 4), are not necessarily associated with significant
alterations in absolute peripheral CD4+ or CD8+ T-cell counts,
despite the fact that chronic antigenic exposure might have been expected
to render these patients particularly susceptible to lymphocyte subset
alterations. Infections linked to at least transient depression in CD4
counts (including tuberculosis, hepatitis B, and EBV-associated mononucleosis)
are usually associated with a CD4:CD8 ratio > 1.0, even if it is statistically
lower than control ratios. This finding also appears to be typical of other
opportunistic infections seen in patients with HIV, including toxoplasmosis
and P. carinii pneumonia (see Table 3). For oral candidiasisref1,
ref2
[64, 65] and cryptococcosisref1,
ref2
[66, 67], the numbers of HIV-seronegative patients studied are still too
small to permit definitive conclusions. The major exception to the generalization
that infectious disorders do not cause a low CD4 count in conjunction with
a CD4:CD8 ratio of less than 1.0 is acute cytomegalovirus infection, in
which depression of CD4 counts is typically accompanied by a marked increase
in CD8 values (see Table 3). Both usually return to baseline after resolution
of cytomegalovirus disease, with no statistical difference in absolute
CD4+ or CD8+ T-cell counts in cytomegalovirus-seropositive compared with
seronegative persons (see Table 2). Human T-cell lymphotropic virus type
II (HTLV-II) occurs in a substantial portion of intravenous drug abusers
and some homosexual men at risk for HIV and is capable of altering CD4
counts for prolonged periods. In HTLV-II-positive persons whose T cells
do not exhibit spontaneous proliferation in vitro, T-cell subsets
do not differ from those of normal controlsref
[61]. Among most HTLV-II- positive persons whose cells do exhibit such
spontaneous growth, however, a significant increase in both CD4+ and CD8+
T-cell subsets, without alteration in CD4:CD8 ratio, has been reported
(see Table 3). Lymphopenia, with artificial lowering of absolute
counts, affects T-cell phenotype in the presence of certain infectious
diseases or congenital disorders. Reference ranges for analysis of disease-related
variations by T-cell subset percentages may be more appropriate in this
settingref1,
ref2
[17, 71], but these results do not alter our approach to assessing T-cell
changes. Transient alterations in CD4 values in infectious diseases also
occur in HIV-seropositive persons. These changes may have clinical relevance,
although their pathophysiologic nature is incompletely understood. For
example, primary cytomegalovirus infection in HIV+ persons may
initiate a more rapid and substantial decline in CD4+ T-cell
counts than in HIV+ controls not exposed to cytomegalovirusref
[72]. The risk for advanced HIV disease in cytomegalovirus-seropositive
persons was 2.5 times that of a similar cytomegalovirus-negative cohortref
[72].
Congenital conditions that may be recognized late in life : common
variable immunodeficiency may lead to altered CD4 counts recognized in
later life. It is an important exclusion criterion for ICL/SUHISref1,
ref2
[4, 8]. Although progressive decreases in CD4+ T cells were
not documented during a 2-year follow-up of HIV-seronegative and culture-negative
patients with CVIDref
[73], including those with low baseline CD4 valuesref
[39], initial absolute counts may be substantially less than the usual
mean. Although CD4: CD8 ratios < 1.0 are unusual in common variable
immunodeficiencyref
[73], they have been reportedref1,
ref2
[39, 74], unfortunately, in the absence of documentation of HIV serostatus.
In these cases, CD4+ T-cell subset analysis may be illuminating
because decrements in CD4 count appear to be secondary to a dramatic deficit
in those cells that induce CD8+ suppressor cells, the CD4+ CD45RA+
population (126 ± 91 compared with 384 ± 142 in controls;
P < 0.001), whereas the CD4+ CD29+ "memory" subset, which
induces helper cells, remains unaffectedref
[39]. All of these analyses beg the issue of qualitative defects
in CD4+ T-cell function occurring in the absence of quantitative
changes. Such alterations are seen in the early stages of HIV infectionref
[75] and may underlie increased susceptibility to opportunistic infections
occurring in the absence of changes in absolute CD4 count. They are beyond
the scope of this review.
Importance of biologic variability in assessing CD4+ T lymphocytopenia
and severe unexplained HIV-negative immunosuppression : because myriad
factors can affect T-cell subsets, changes in CD4+ T-cell counts
should be investigated over time, together with the CD4:CD8 ratio, particularly
in the context of intercurrent disease. This is especially important in
evaluating patients with ICL/SUHIS and should aid in refining its definition.
For example, case 5 from 5 reports of idiopathic CD4+ T lymphocytopeniaref
[3] was a sexually active homosexual man, negative for HIV by serologic
testing and DNA amplification by polymerase chain reaction, who had pulmonary
tuberculosis, a persistent but stable CD4 count < 300/ml,
and a CD4: CD8 ratio < 1.0. 6 months after successful therapy for his
tuberculosis, his CD4 counts increased to > 600/ml,
making the diagnosis of ICL/SUHIS untenable. Indeed, in all of the few
patients with ICL/SUHIS investigated by reverse transcriptase measurements
in viral culturesref1,
ref2
[4, 6], no evidence for retroviral activity has been found. These patients
have not shown progressive declines in their CD4 counts, however, and thus
have been accurately described as not having an "HIV-like" immunologic
picture. It has been estimated recently that > 300,000 persons in the USA
alone would meet the current definition of idiopathic CD4+ T
lymphocytopenia, with the possible involvement of a novel agent(s) lost
within this mixture of uncertain lower truncation point for CD4 distribution
and statistical variationsref
[76]. Thus, the failure to detect a lymphocytopathic or retrovirus or other
micro-organisms should not discourage a thorough analysis of that subset
of ICL/SUHIS patients with T-cell changes more characteristic of HIV. They
should undergo extensive evaluation for HIV or other recognized or novel
infectious causes of immune deficiencyref1,
ref2
[3, 77]. Such patients represent a very small fraction of the total cases
reported to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and the World
Health Organizationref1,
ref2,
ref3,
ref4,
ref5,
ref6
[3-8]. I believe that it is these persons, however, for whom pneumocystis
prophylaxis should be considered after CD4 counts decrease to < 200/ml,
regardless of whether a retrovirus or other infectious agent has been identified.
In the absence of clear epidemiologic support for a transmissible agent,
however, any recommendation concerning ICL/SUHIS must be presented with
great reserve. For example, a "novel retrovirus" was reported to have been
isolated from two HIV-seronegative patients with CVIDref
[78] who, unlike the typical cases summarized here, had very low CD4 counts
as well as depressed CD4:CD8 ratios. Follow-up showed that these patients
were actively infected with HIV-1, even if incompetent to mount a serologic
response to itref
[73]. Finally, apart from T-cell subset analyses, AIDS in the "pre-AIDS
era" had been describedref
[79] before recognition of ICL/SUHIS, but in only 1 of these 19 patients
with opportunistic infections were CD4 counts measured. Indeed, my colleagues
and I had previously documented P. carinii pneumonia in patients with normal
CD4 counts and CD4:CD8 ratiosref
[63], and similar reports of AIDS-linked illnesses in patients with normal
CD4 counts and T-cell subset ratios have been publishedref
[80]. It is only through careful follow-up of patients screened in the
manner suggested here, using historical knowledge of the effects of various
infectious diseases and conditions on immunophenotyping, that complex issues
such as physiologic CD4+ lymphopenia, ICL/SUHIS, requirements
for institution of prophylactic antibiotics, and potential new infectious
agents associated with alterations in T-cell subsets can be assessed.
-
granulocytes (granulocytopenia)
-
agranulocytosis / agranulocytic or neutropenic
angina / malignant or pernicious leukopenia / Schultz's angina or syndrome
/ idiopathic or malignant neutropenia
: any condition involving greatly
decreased numbers of granulocytes
Aetiology :
-
sensitization to drugs
-
chemicals
-
vesnarinone
is an important new drug that significantly decreases mortality rates in
severe congestive heart failure; however, its use is associated with a
relatively high incidence (approximately 1%) of agranulocytosisref
-
radiation affecting the bone marrow and depressing granulopoiesis
Symptoms & signs : severe neutropenia
results in lesions of the throat, other mucous membranes, gastrointestinal
tract, and skin
-
neutropenia : absolute neutrophil count
(ANC) < 2s below the age-related mean
-
peripheral neutropenia : decrease in the number of neutrophils in
the circulating blood.
Grading :
-
mild neutropenia : ANC = 1000-1500/mm3
-
moderate neutropenia : 500-1000/mm3
-
severe neutropenia : < 500/mm3
Epidemiology : 1-2 cases per million population;
incidence is the same in males and females.
Onset :
-
congenital neutropenia (CN) / chronic hypoplastic neutropenia :
former names for infantile genetic agranulocytosis. The 2 mains forms of
hereditary neutropenia are cyclic neutropenia, also known as cyclic hematopoiesis,
and severe congenital neutropenia (SCN), sometimes referred to as Kostmann
syndrome. Other syndromes can feature neutropenia as a component :
|
syndrome
|
inheritance
|
gene
|
clinical features
|
animal model
|
animal model phenotype
|
| cyclic neutropenia |
autosomal dominant |
ELA2 |
alternate 21 day cycling of neutrophils and monocytes |
mouse
knock-out |
-
no neutropenia
-
resistance to smoking-induced COPD
-
vulnerability to infection
|
| severe congenital
neutropenia (SCN) |
autosomal dominant |
ELA2
(35–84%) |
-
static neutropenia
-
MDS and AML
|
mouse knock-in (V72M) |
no obvious phenotype |
| autosomal dominant |
Gfi1
(rare) |
-
static neutropenia
-
circulating myeloid progenitors
-
lymphopenia
|
mouse
knock-out |
resembles human Gfi1 deficiency |
| sex-linked |
wASP
(rare) |
neutropenic variant of
Wiskott-Aldrich
syndrome |
mouse
knock-out |
-
lymphopenia
-
thrombocytopenia
-
colitis
|
| autosomal dominant |
G-CSFR
(rare) |
-
G-CSF refractory neutropenia
-
no documented MDS
or AML
|
mouse
knock-out |
-
moderate neutropenia
-
decreased progenitors in bone marrow
-
increased apoptosis in circulating neutrophils
|
Kostmann
syndrome |
autosomal recessive |
unknown |
static neutropenia without
MDS
or AML |
|
|
Hermansky-Pudlak
syndrome ,
type 2 |
autosomal recessive |
AP3B1 |
-
SCN
-
platelet dense body defects
-
oculocutaneous albinism
|
gray collie
syndrome
of dogs |
-
14-day cycles of pancytopenia
-
coat and eye color changes
|
-
mouse pearl mutation
-
mouse knockout
|
-
no documented neutropenia
-
platelet dense body defects
-
coat and eye color changes
|
Chediak-Higashi
syndrome |
autosomal recessive |
LYST |
-
neutropenia
-
oculocutaneous albinism
-
giant lysosomes
-
lymphohistiocytic infiltration
-
impaired platelet function
|
blue-smoke Persian cat |
-
neutropenia
-
coat and eye color changes
-
giant lysosomes
-
lymphohistiocytic infiltration
-
impaired platelet function
|
-
mouse beige mutation
-
cattle
-
Aleutian mink
|
-
no neutropenia
-
coat and eye color changes
-
giant lysosomes
-
lymphohistiocytic infiltration
-
impaired platelet function
|
| Barth syndrome |
sex-linked |
TAZ |
-
neutropenia, often cyclic
-
dilated cardiomyopathy
-
methylglutaconic-aciduria
|
|
|
| Cohen syndrome |
autosomal recessive |
COH1 |
-
mental retardation
-
neutropenia
-
dysmorphism
|
|
|
Aetiology :
-
cyclic
or periodic neutropenia / cyclic hematopoiesis / gray collie syndrome
Aetiology : rare autosomal dominant (autosomal
recessive in gray collie dogs) in which there is a bone marrow stem cell
defect. As with other dominant disorders, sporadic cases commonly arise
from new mutations. Genetic linkage analysis and positional cloning demonstrated
that heterozygous, germline mutations of the ELA2
gene, encoding neutrophil elastase, explain many cases of cyclic neutropeniaref.
There are many different alleles, but the most common are intronic substitutions
that destroy a splice donor site in intron 4. This forces the utilization
of an upstream, cryptic splice donor site resulting in an internal deletion
of 10 amino acid residues from the protein (V161-F170).
Symptoms & signs : life-threatening
infections can accompany the 3- to 4-day neutropenic nadir of the cycle,
with frequent aphthous stomatitis, periodontitis, typhlitis, and occasional
sepsis. There may be particular vulnerability to infection with anaerobic
bacteria, suggesting that the deficiency in neutrophils is not merely one
of low numbers
Laboratory examinations : a chronic type
of neutropenia with approximately 21-day fluctuations in numbers of circulating
neutrophils (and platelets, and reticulocytes) with a nadir approaching
zero and a peak near normalref.
Monocytes cycle but do so in a phase opposite to that of neutrophils. Similar
periodicity may occur in acquired diseases, including chronic
myelogenous leukemia (CML)
,
large
granular lymphocytosis (LGL), and hypereosinophilic
syndrome
Prognosis : in general, patients with
cyclic neutropenia do not develop leukemia, although there are a few exceptionsref
Therapy : most cases respond to G-CSF
treatment, administered at about 2–3 µg/kg at 1- to 2-day intervalsref.
G-CSF does not abrogate cycling, but instead reduces infectious complications
by shortening the cycle period and increasing the amplitude of the waves
-
Kostmann
congenital agranulocytosis neutropenia / infantile genetic agranulocytosis
/ severe congenital neutropenia (SCN)ref
Epidemiology : most of the initial patients
reported by Kostmann were seen in a consanguineous family of Överkalix
parish in northern Sweden, a geographic region with excessive inbreeding.
Aetiology : SCN is genetically heterogeneous,
and most cases seem to arise sporadically, consistent with its transmission
as an often lethal, autosomal dominant disorder.
-
heterozygous ELA2
mutations are present in DNA extracted from the peripheral blood of
35–84% of SCN casesref,
leading to increased SHP-1 and SHP-2 in neutrophils. SCN is genetically
heterogeneous, and most cases seem to arise sporadically, consistent with
its transmission as an often lethal, autosomal dominant disorder. A rare
case of sex-linked recessive inheritance has been described and constitutes
an allelic variant of the Wiskott-Aldrich
syndrome
ref.
Most cases are sporadic, but ELA2 mutations segregate with multigenerational
transmission of the disease in several pedigrees where there are multiple
affected family members, thus indicating that the mutations, at least in
familial cases, occur constitutionally in the germline. The possibility
of somatic ELA2 mutations, similar to the case for G-CSFR, remains unexplored.
Mutations causing SCN are generally distinct from those responsible for
cyclic neutropenia. The genotypes and phenotypes can overlapref1,
ref2,
however, and the mutation P110L appears roughly equally among both cyclic
neutropenia and SCN patient populations. Chain terminating nonsense and
frameshift mutations near the carboxyl terminus are the most common SCN
mutations. SCN patients whose disease is the result of ELA2 mutations represent
a subset with worse disease: lower neutrophil counts, requirement for higher
doses of G-CSF to achieve a response, and higher rate of neoplastic progressionref.
Some ELA2 mutations are particularly severe. G185R occurs in 4 SCN patients
known in the French neutropenia registryref
and each of whom has failed G-CSF treatment and has developed MDS or AML
-
homozygous mutation of ELA2 is unknown, and this gene would be an
unlikely candidate for the recessive syndrome first reported by Kostmann,
where the responsible gene remains unidentified.
Symptoms & signs : temperature instability
in newborn period, fever, irritability, localized site(s) of infection,
oral ulcers, gingivitis, pharyngitis, sinusitis, otitis media, lymphadenopathy
and/or lymphadenitis, bronchitis and/or pneumonia, cellulitis, boils, cutaneous
abscess, omphalitis, perianal abscess, lung abscess, liver abscess, peritonitis,
enteritis with chronic diarrhea and vomiting, bacteremia and/or septicemia,
urinary tract infection, fractures. Bone demineralization resulting in
bone pain and unusual fractures occur in approximately 50% of patients,
either as a part of the pathophysiology of the disease or potentially from
either endogenous or exogenous G-CSFs by increased bone resorption. Acute
myeloid leukemia
may develop in approximately 5-7% of patients, which suggests that Kostmann
disease is a preleukemic syndrome. Because of the prolonged survival rate
of patients with G-CSF therapy, the frequency of leukemias may increase.
Although G-CSF receptor mutation does not appear responsible for the initial
neutropenia in Kostmann disease, leukemic transformation is associated
with this spontaneous mutation.
Laboratory examinations :
-
static ANC < 500/mm3, monocytosis and eosinophilia => normal
TLC
-
mild anemia may be present from chronic inflammation
-
hypergammaglobulinemia
-
normal complementemia, no ANCA
-
cytomorphology : bone marrow aspiration or biopsy reveals an arrest of
neutrophil precursor maturation at the promyelocyte or myelocyte level
-
immunophenotype : neutrophils are CD16 / FcgRIIlow
and CD64 / FcgRIhigh
-
normal ROS generation and intracellular killing of bacteria
-
decreased intracellular calcium mobilization in response to fMLP or IL-8
-
cytogenetic analysis typically reveals a normal bone marrow karyotype
Differential diagnosis : GSD-1, SCID, Chediak-Higashi
syndrome
,
myelokathexis
Therapy :
-
prophylactic antibiotics may be considered but are not usually required
-
steroids and testosterone is not effective.
-
drain abscess as needed.
-
splenectomy
is not effective
-
G-CSF
(at higher doses than those used to treat cyclic neutropeniaref)
remains a highly efficacious therapy to prevent serious infectionsref
: 29% of patients who receive G-CSF for 10 years will either die from sepsis
(8%) or develop MDS
/AML
(21%)ref.
Those who receive a daily G-CSF dose greater than 8 µg/kg yet show
neutrophil counts that are below the mean for the entire group have a cumulative
incidence of either fatal sepsis or myeloid leukemia of 55%. Importantly,
the myeloid malignancies that develop in patients with SCN show adverse
biologic features such as chromosome 7 deletions. Mutations of G-CSFR
,
the gene encoding the G-CSF receptor, which almost exclusively occur in
SCN, were initially reported as causative of some SCN casesref1,
ref2.
Later, it was appreciated that G-CSFR mutations represent acquired,
nonheritable, somatic events in the bone marrow, accumulating as SCN
progresses to MDS and AML, although the mutations do not invariantly occur
in AML and may also appear in the absence of neoplasiaref1,
ref2
: Lyn and Hck as key negative regulators of granulopoiesis and raise the
possibility that loss of Src-family kinase activation by the d715 truncation
mutation in G-CSFR may contribute to its hyperproliferative phenotyperef.
This potentially lifesaving treatment should not be withheld from newly
diagnosed patients due to the risk of leukemia later in life. Leukemia
in SCN may also show acquired monosomy 7, trisomy 21, and ras mutations.
Subsequently, there have been reports of 2 sporadic SCN patients, resistant
to G-CSF therapy, with constitutional heterozygous G-CSFR mutations that
do appear to represent new pathogenetic germline mutations. The possibility
of somatic ELA2 mutations in MDS or AML arising in the absence of hereditary
neutropenia has not been addressed.
-
allogeneic HSCT
is the preferred treatment for patients with CN who have a matched sibling
donor, are unresponsive to therapy with G-CSF or in those with leukemic
transformation
Web resources : Severe
Chronic Neutropenia International Registry (SCNIR)
-
Gänsslen
familial neutropenia
-
Hitzig
chronic benign familial neutropenia : a rare familial type of peripheral
neutropenia, probably transmitted as an autosomal dominant trait, related
to but less severe than agranulocytosis. It is usually seen in children
and is characterized by recurrent infections with eventual spontaneous
remission, but in a few cases it has persisted into adulthood
-
reticular
dysgenesia
-
Shwachman-Diamond
syndrome (SDS)

-
Whim
syndrome : myelokathexis
(the occurrence of neutropenia and retention of bone marrow neutrophils
has been called myelokathexis (kathexis = retention)), combination of chronic
papillomavirus and bacterial sinopulmonary infections, low immunoglobulin
levels.
Pathogenesis : genetic data supporting the
role of ELA2 mutation in the pathogenesis of cyclic neutropenia and SCN
have been confirmed independently in several laboratoriesref.
Clinical Laboratory Improvement Amendment (CLIA)-certified tests to detect
ELA2 mutation are commercially available. Nevertheless, the finding that
such a pedestrian enzyme as neutrophil elastase causes hereditary neutropenia
was greeted with skepticism. At least two further observations unambiguously
establish causality. First, the probability of identifying by chance a
new mutation—an extremely rare occurrence—when screening a single gene,
from among > 20,000 human genes, in a sporadic case whose unaffected parents
lack the illness, is infinitesimal. Yet, for sporadic cases, new mutation
of ELA2 occurs invariantly in cyclic neutropenia and commonly in SCN. Second,
germline mosaic individualsref
who have fathered children with SCN demonstrate ELA2 mutations in myeloid
progenitors, but not neutrophils, indicating that the mutation alone is
sufficient to prevent the maturation of stem cells into neutrophils (or
to direct them to an alternate cell fate, such as monocytes). A debate
focusing on the origins of MDS and AML in SCN has drawn two sides. One
argues that malignant evolution is a consequence of bone marrow failure
per se, noting that clinically and genetically distinct cytopenic disorders,
such as Shwachman-Diamond syndrome, also undergo such transformation. The
other centers on the possible contributions of G-CSF treatment. In fact,
neither argument may be correct. Epidemiological data do not reveal an
association between G-CSF dose or duration of treatment and neoplasiaref.
Recent observations indicate that even though SCN patients without ELA2
mutations generally have clinically indistinguishable disease, MDS or AML
arises almost exclusively in the subset of SCN patients whose illness is
caused by ELA2 mutationsref.
Neutrophil elastase could thus be the first protease known to act as an
oncoprotein. In fact, it may have a role in other malignancies. Genetic
deficiency of a1-antitrypsin, the
major inhibitor of neutrophil elastase, is associated with an increased
risk of (in addition to pulmonary emphysema) lymphoma and carcinoma of
the lung, liver, gall bladder, and bladderref.
Common sequence variants of the ELA2 promoter that cause its overexpression
are found at higher frequency in lung cancer patients. The beige mouse,
a genetic model of the human neutropenic Chediak-Higashi
syndrome
resulting from LYST mutation and leading to secondary deficiency of neutrophil
elastase, is resistant to UV- and benzopyrene-induced skin cancer. ELA2
is expressed only in promyelocytes and promonocytes, but the neutrophil
elastase protein persists through the cell divisions of terminal differentiation
to neutrophils and monocytes, respectivelyref.
The mature protein is 218 amino acids in length (following removal of pre-pro
amino terminal sequences and a carboxyl tail). Neutrophil elastase predominately
resides in granules but is also present in the plasma membrane and released
into serum. As a chymotryptic protease, it is capable of digesting many
substrates, including matrix components such as elastin, clotting factors,
immunoglobulins, and complement. Intriguingly, with respect to disease
pathogenesis, neutrophil elastase also cleaves G-CSF, the G-CSF receptor,
the c-KIT receptor, and Notch family receptorsref.
Nevertheless, in crude recombinant expression assays, the mutations have
varying effects on catalytic activity, with some markedly reducing activity
and others appearing to be largely inconsequentialref.
Given this background, determining how the mutations cause disease has
proven to be elusive. The proposal that these ELA2 mutations cause accelerated
apoptosis has been called into questionref.
Cyclic neutropenia in dogs, also known as the gray collie syndrome,
differs from the human form of the illness because it features autosomal
recessive inheritance, oculocutaneous albinism, cycling of all blood lineages,
and a periodicity closer to 2, instead of 3, weeks. A candidate gene approach
found that canine cyclic neutropenia is the equivalent of the rare human
Hermansky-Pudkak
syndrome
type 2 (HPS2), with both diseases resulting from homozygous inactivating
mutations of AP3B1, encoding the beta subunit of the adaptor protein 3
(AP3) trafficking complexref.
There are just 4 patients from 3 families known to have HPS2; all are neutropenic,
and, in the only patient in whom cycling was investigated, the neutropenia
was severe and staticref.
As recently reviewedref,
there are 4 heterotetrameric adapter protein complexes, and all are involved
in the intracellular transport of luminal "cargo" proteins within membrane-bound
organelles. AP3 specifically shuttles cargo proteins from the trans-Golgi
network to lysosomes, which, in neutrophils, generally correspond to granules.
The mu or beta subunits recognize tyrosine or dileucine based peptide motifs,
respectively, within cargo proteins. In the absence of AP3, cargo proteins
are routed to a default destination in the plasma membrane. Mutations yielding
absence of beta subunits lead to disassembly and decay of the entire complex.
Several lines of evidence suggest that neutrophil elastase is a cargo protein
for AP3ref.
First, its localization in granules is compatible with the distribution
of other known AP3 cargo proteins, and mutations in either cause similar
diseases. Furthermore, neutrophil elastase is deficient in canine cyclic
neutropenia, even though the canine ELA2 gene is intact and appropriately
expressed. Finally, neutrophil elastase (processed free of its carboxyl
tail) and the AP3 mu subunit interact in a yeast two-hybrid assay, and
a tyrosine residue in neutrophil elastase (NE) is required for their association.
The most common category of SCN mutations—those that delete the carboxyl
terminus—also remove the tyrosine residue required for association in
vitro between neutrophil elastase and the mu subunit of AP3 and redirect
neutrophil elastase to the plasma membrane in transfected cells. Nevertheless,
these observations raise a potential biological problem. AP3 coats the
cytoplasmic (outer) surface of membrane-bound organelles, and cargo proteins,
within the interior of such vesicles, must extrude through the membrane
in order to interact with AP3. Thus, if neutrophil elastase is a genuine
AP3 cargo protein, then it must have at least one transmembrane segment.
Neutrophil elastase, a textbook serine protease, has been extremely well
studied. Although routinely appearing on membranes, it had generally been
regarded as a soluble protein. Somewhat surprisingly, several, though not
all, computer algorithms designed to predict transmembrane domains detect
two such segments in neutrophil elastaseref.
Interestingly, when the location of mutations is superimposed on the predicted
transmembrane domains, a striking pattern emerges : mutations capable of
causing cyclic neutropenia approximately overlap with predicted transmembrane
segments. Experimentally, expression of neutrophil elastase representing
cyclic neutropenia mutations in proposed transmembrane segments appears
to cause enhanced granular accumulation of the protein, whereas wild-type
protein also shows some distribution in the plasma membrane. Fit of ELA2
mutations into 1 of 3 proposed functional categories.
The linear sequence of the protein is marked with respect to the processed
pre-pro amino and carboxyl termini, predicted transmembrane domains (TM-1
and TM-2), cryptic transmembrane (TM-cryptic) domain predicted as a result
of some mutations, and proposed recognition site of the AP3 mu subunit.
Squares represent mutations exclusively causing severe congenital neutropenia
(SCN). Circles indicate mutations found in cyclic neutropenia patients
(but that may also appear in SCN patients). Horizontal lines depict deletions.
Lines connected by right angles reveal disulfide bonds that generally bracket
predicted transmembrane domains, with mutated cysteine residues at their
corners. Missense mutations generally aligning with transmembrane domains
are colored black. Mutations destroying disulfide bonds are shaded light
gray. Chain terminating nonsense and frameshift mutations that delete the
AP3 mu recognition signal are shaded dark gray. Each mutationref
is shown once. Mutations unaccounted for by this classification scheme
are listed in the text, but not charted. Gfi1 encodes a zinc finger transcriptional
repressor oncoprotein identified in a retroviral screen for IL-2 growth-independence
of lymphomas. It regulates a subset of genes governing myeloid differentiation,
including ELA2ref.
Gene targeting unexpectedly revealed neutropenia in Gfi1-deficient mice.
Consequently, a screen of 105 neutropenic individuals (49 with SCN and
56 with nonimmune
chronic idiopathic neutropenia of adults (NI-CINA), incorporating milder
neutropenia diagnosed as an adult) lacking ELA2 mutations led to the identification
of two different, heterozygous, autosomal dominant Gfi1 zinc finger missense
mutations in a family of 3 SCN patients and in an NI-CINA patientref.
One mutation, N382S in the fifth zinc finger, disrupts DNA binding and
another, K403R, perturbs a lysine residue that may serve as a site for
posttranslational modification with the SUMO polypeptide. SUMO is involved
in DNA replication and repair, nuclear-cytoplasmic transport, and subnuclear
localization. The clinical features of human Gfi1 mutation resemble the
mouse knock-out and, in addition to neutropenia, consist of circulating
primitive myeloid cells and B cell and CD4 T cell lymphopenia. A group
has proposed a somewhat speculative model for how mutations in neutrophil
elastase, adaptor protein 3, and Gfi1 cause cyclic and congenital neutropenia
and HPS2. Neutrophil elastase can exist in both soluble and transmembrane
conformations. (In the soluble isoform, the transmembrane segments are
folded into disulfide-bonded loops.) Processing of the carboxyl tail exposes
a tyrosine-based signal permitting its recognition and transport to granules
as an AP3 cargo protein. There are 4 categories of mutationsref.
Proposed model of normal and pathological processing and transport of neutrophil
elastase :
The product of the ELA2 gene, neutrophil elastase (NE), is shown in
the membrane of the trans Golgi network (TGN). If the C-terminus
is cleaved, then NE normally interacts with AP3 (via the mu subunit of
AP3 recognizing a tyrosine residue, depicted by a black dot, in the cytoplasmic
tail of NE), which transports it to granules, where NE re-equilibrates
into a soluble form. If the C-terminus remains intact, then interaction
with AP3 is blocked and NE is routed to a default destination in the plasma
and other membranes. In SCN, deletions of the AP3 recognition signal or
missense mutations that favor a transmembrane configuration of NE increase
trafficking through the membrane pathway. Mutations of AP3 itself, as in
canine cyclic neutropenia and HPS2, act similarly. In cyclic neutropenia,
mutations disrupting the transmembrane segments favor a shift in equilibrium
to soluble forms accumulating in granules. Mutations of Gfi1 lead to overexpression
of ELA2, overwhelming normal AP3-mediated trafficking and diverting excess
NE to membranes. The most commonly occurring ELA2 mutations in SCN prematurely
terminate neutrophil elastase and delete the AP3 recognition signal, thereby
sending neutrophil elastase to the plasma membrane, the default destination
for cargo proteins in the absence of AP3. In HPS2, the absence of AP3 similarly
redirects neutrophil elastase to the plasma membrane. Mutations of Gfi1
lead to overexpression of neutrophil elastase, which overwhelms normal
AP3-based granular transport pathways and leads to excessive accumulation
in the plasma membrane. Upregulating ELA2 promoter variants may act similarly
to cause SCNref.
Mutations that can produce cyclic neutropenia tend to disrupt transmembrane
segments, thus favoring a shift toward a soluble form of neutrophil elastase,
predominately localizing intraluminally within granules. It is possible
that mistrafficking of neutrophil elastase causes neutropenia in other
syndromes in which neutropenia is a component feature. For example, in
the beige mouse model of the human neutropenic disorder Chediak-Higashi
syndrome
,
posttranslational processing and trafficking of neutrophil elastase is
disturbedref.
The autosomal recessive Cohen syndrome of mental retardation, dysmorphic
features, and neutropenia results from mutation of COH1, encoding a protein
with homology to the yeast protein VPS13, involved in vesicle sorting and
intracellular protein transportref.
Finally, as outlandish as it may be to propose that neutrophil elastase
leads a secret double life as a transmembrane protein, it may have even
more tricks up its sleeve. Neutrophil elastase appears to cleave the PML/RAR
fusion gene, the product of the t(15;17) translocation in FAB M3 AML, and
ELA2-deficient mice expressing a PML/RAR transgene are resistant to the
leukemia that otherwise would developref.
Even more bizarre, a recent report suggests that neutrophil elastase and
chromatin are expulsed together from neutrophils to form net-like, extracellular
traps for bacteriaref.
Neutrophil elastase is turning up in some surprising places.
Laboratory examinations : chronic neutropenia,
recurrent infections, and arrest at the promyelocyte/myelocyte stage of
maturation
Therapy : G-CSF
-
acquired neutropenia : is a relatively
rare disorder
-
immune neutropenia
Aetiology :
-
alloimmune or isoimmune
neonatal neutropenia (AINN) : neutropenia in the newborn due to in
utero incompatibility between its paternal neutrophil antigens and
those of the mother's blood; the mother's blood produces IgG antineutrophil
antibodies that cross the placenta and sensitize fetal neutrophils. Affected
infants may have fever, pneumonia, septicemia, and other infections that
can be fatal. The condition eventually resolves itself as the infant's
immunoglobulin replaces that from the mother. Newborns develop transient
neutropenia that recovers spontaneously after an average of 11 weeks. In
general, infectious complications are minor, and most series report no
septic deathsref.
When necessary, patients respond well to G-CSF
ref.
The majority of patients with AINN develop neutropenia in response to antibodies
directed against antigens of HNA-1. The HNA antigens are located FcgIIIb
(CD16)
.
Pan-FcgRIIIb antibodies can arise in individuals
who lack the receptor altogether as the result of a gene deletion; this
is a rare cause of AINNref.
Although FcgRIII deficiency was first discovered
in the evaluation of patients who had newborns with AINN, the incidence
of the development of antineutrophil antibodies was actually quite low.
For example, in a study of 21 patients with FcgRIIIb
deficiency, among 3 patients with 10 at-risk pregnancies, there were no
newborns with neutropeniaref.
Interestingly, the incidence of AINN appears to be lower than the incidence
of detectable granulocyte-specific antibodies in the population. In one
survey of over 1000 postpartum women, 1.1% demonstrated granulocyte-specific
antibodies, but no newborns had neutropeniaref.
Whether the detected antibodies were false positives inherent in the test
or whether relative clinical silence reflects the biology of antineutrophil
antibodies is unknown
-
autoimmune neutropenia (AIN)
-
primary AIN is a rare disorder. It occurs
predominantly in early childhood: one study of 143 patients with AIN demonstrated
that of 101 patients with primary AIN, 76 patients were under age 3ref.
The average age of onset is 6–12 months, and patients develop a moderate
to severe chronic neutropenia. Infections are usually mild to moderate,
and serious infections are unusual. Spontaneous remission occurs in 95%
of childhood AIN patients over the course of 2 yearsref,
with one group suggesting that the level of detected antibody is predictive
of both infectious complications and time to remissionref.
Treatment with prophylactic antibiotics
ameliorates infectious complications. Although patients are almost uniformly
responsive to G-CSF
,
chronic administration is usually unnecessary and should be reserved for
recurrent or severe infectionsref.
Tests for antineutrophil antibodies in AIN are nearly always detected by
GIFT, but in about 3% of cases may be positive only by GAT. Antibodies
are uniformly IgG, and are directed primarily against HNA1 and 2, with
rarer cases associated with antibodies to CD11b (HNA-5a) or pan-FcgIIIb
(CD16)
ref1,
ref2.
This is in contrast to secondary AIN, where pan-FcgRIIIb
antibodies are frequently detected. Primary AIN is rare in adults, where
autoimmune neutropenia is more often secondary to underlying rheumatologic
syndromes. In adults, infectious complications are also frequently absent
or mild, although the disease is usually chronic and spontaneous recovery
is unusualref.
Again, since symptoms may be minimal, treatment should be based on the
patient’s clinical course rather than on the absolute level of the neutrophil
count
-
secondary AIN : secondary AIN in adults
is usually associated with systemic autoimmune disease, predominantly rheumatoid
arthritis (RA) and SLEref.
Neutropenia in RA is usually attributable to :
-
Felty’s syndrome
(FS)
typically occurs in patients with longstanding RA associated with end-organ
manifestations of RA, including pulmonary fibrosis, vasculitis, rheumatoid
nodules, and splenomegaly. Patients may also have Sjögren’s syndrome.
Patients may have considerable morbidity from bacterial infection and may
in rare cases succumb to overwhelming sepsisref.
Laboratory evaluation of patients with FS demonstrates high levels of rheumatoid
factor, circulating immune complexes, and hypergammaglobulinemia. In addition,
many patients may be antinuclear antibody (ANA)+. 90% of patients
with FS are HLA-DR4+
-
T-LGL
leukemia
: interestingly, patients with LGL leukemia share this incidence of HLA-DR4.
This and other pathophysiologic features of the disease have prompted some
investigators to suggest that FS and LGL leukemia represent a spectrum
of the same disease processref.
-
SLE
-associated
neutropenia : neutropenia occurs in approximately half of patients
with SLE. It is rarely severe and serves more as a marker of disease activity
than as a clinically important complication. Neutropenia has little impact
on the course of the disease and does not appear to predispose to an increase
in infectious complications. The incidence of infectious complications
is more reflective of immunosuppressive therapy than the height of the
neutrophil countref.
Neutropenia in SLE has been attributed to neutrophil-specific antibodies,
to increased apoptosis of neutrophils, and to decreased marrow neutrophil
production. All of these effects appear to be antibody-mediated. Increased
neutrophil-associated IgG has been detected in half of patients diagnosed
with SLE, but not all patients are neutropenicref.
This further supports the observation that interpretation of increased
neutrophil-associated IgG is especially difficult in the presence of immune
complex disease. Both immune complexes and neutrophil antigen-specific
antibodies have been implicated in the pathogenesis of SLE-associated neutropenia,
but the correlation between laboratory testing and clinical neutropenia
is poor. Some investigators have hypothesized that antinuclear antibodies
may crossreact with neutrophil surface antigens, either because of crossreactive
epitopes or because the nuclear antigens themselves are expressed on the
cell surface. Neutropenia in SLE has been hypothesized to be pathogenetically
related to the presence of anti-SSA (Ro) and anti-SSB (La) antibodies.
Anti-Ro antibodies have been shown to bind a crossreacting antigen on the
neutrophil cell surface and to fix complement. In another studyref,
immunoscreening of a leukocyte expression library identified La as an antigen
bound by antineutrophil-positive sera from patients with SLE; this too
was demonstrated to increase neutrophil apoptosis, as well as decreasing
phagocytosis and increasing IL-8 productionref.
Finally, some antibodies have been demonstrated to be reactive against
early myeloid progenitors, leading to decreased neutrophil productionref
-
secondary AIN in childhood is rare and may be associated with autoimmune
lymphoproliferative syndrome (ALPS)
.
This disorder is caused by heterozygous mutations in the fas gene, leading
to abnormalities of lymphoid apoptosis. ALPS is associated with autoimmune
cytopenias in association with adenopathy and splenomegaly. Patients have
increased numbers of circulating double negative (CD4–, CD8–)
T cells. ALPS is associated with a markedly increased incidence of non-Hodgkin’s
lymphoma
ref
Pathogenesis : antibodies directed against
neutrophil-specific antigensref.
Antineutrophil antibodies are directed against a defined group of neutrophil-specific
glycoproteinsref1,
ref2,
ref3,
ref4
defined in 1998 by the Granulocyte Antigen Working Party of the International
Society of Blood Transfusionsref.
Laboratory examinations : detection of antineutrophil
antibodies.
-
most widely performed
-
granulocyte agglutination test (GAT) : incubation of granulocytes
with patient sera (as in indirect Coombs test) and microscopic evaluation
of agglutination. Results with this assay are reported to have widely varied
rates of sensitivity, depending on the procedures used.
-
granulocyte immunofluorescence test (GIFT) : detection of neutrophil-bound
antibody (as in direct Coombs test) by binding of glutaraldehyde-fixed
patient neutrophils to fluorescently labeled anti-human IgG. Glutaraldehyde
fixation prevents spontaneous fluorescence of neutrophils, which can confound
interpretation of the test. The assay can be performed directly on patient
neutrophils, although this may be difficult if the patient is profoundly
neutropenic. Direct assay for the presence of antibody bound to neutrophils,
either on patient neutrophils or on heterologous neutrophils incubated
with patient serum or plasma, is fraught with difficultyref.
Because neutrophils have abundant Fc receptors, false positive results
may complicate interpretation of any of these studies, especially in the
presence of high levels of circulating antibodies (as in myeloma or HIV
infection) or in the setting of immune complex disease. Furthermore, neutrophils
are fragile, tend to aggregate spontaneously in vitro, and often
lyse upon manipulation, complicating interpretation of direct assays further.
The degree to which these difficulties are estimated to complicate the
interpretation of the assays varies among investigators. However, it may
explain the presence of detectable antibodies in certain nonneutropenic
study populations as well as the lack of correlation between the level
of detected antibody and the degree of neutropenia reported by most investigators.
-
granulocyte indirect immunofluorescence test (GIIFT) (as in indirect
Coombs test) : detection of serum antibody by incubation with glutaraldehyde-fixed
heterologous normal neutrophils with patient serum with subsequent staining
with fluorescently labeled anti-human IgG. This can be further adapted
by using typed neutrophils homozygous for known neutrophil antigens, allowing
identification of the target antigen of the patient’s antibody. Fluorescence
can be detected by inspection under a microscope or by flow cytometry
-
enzyme linked immunoassays (ELISA) : detection of antibody in serum
by binding to glutaraldehyde-fixed normal neutrophils on microtiter plates
with detection by conjugated anti-human IgG
-
monoclonal antibody-specific immobilization of granulocyte antigens
(MAIGA) : simultaneous incubation of neutrophils with defined antigen
specificity with patient serum and monoclonal antibodies directed against
neutrophil-specific antigens. Antigens are then immobilized on column coated
with anti-mouse ab, and assayed for presence of human antibodyref.
This allows for the direct and simultaneous determination of antibody specificity
directed at a variety of antigens. Tests of neutrophil antibodies are less
widely performed and are more difficult to interpret than comparable tests
on erythrocytes.
-
primary splenic neutropenia / hypersplenic
neutropenia : a syndrome characterized by splenomegaly
,
hypercellular bone marrow, profound leukopenia and neutropenia, and susceptibility
to infection, occasionally with anemia and thrombocytopenia
-
drug-induced neutropenia
is an idiosyncratic reaction that results in profound neutropenia or agranulocytosisref.
Unlike the chronic immune neutropenias, which have a surprisingly low rate
of morbidity and mortality, drug-induced neutropenia is associated with
a high rate of infectious complications and has a mortality rate of approximately
10%ref1,
ref2.
The most common drugs associated with agranulocytosis are antithyroid medications
and sulfonamides. The most common mechanisms are immunological (formation
of antibodies destructive to neutrophils or of immune complexes that bind
to neutrophils), followed by inhibition of granulopoiesis and direct damage
to bone marrow or precursor cells of the granulocytic series.
-
antithyroid medications :